Home Blog Page 293

TNG “All Good Things…” Blu-ray: New HD Trailer!

Hot on the heels of the newly-released Blu-ray trailer for Star Trek: The Next Generation – Season 7, CBS Home Entertainment has also given us a first look at the upcoming single-disc Blu-ray release of “All Good Things…”, the TNG series finale.

[iframe src=”http://www.youtube.com/embed/jRbXqqyRmGY” width=”560″ height=”315″]
 

“All Good Things…” is cinematic in scope, and the trailer does a wonderful job at whetting our appetite for the remastered version. The three-nacelled, alternate-future Enterprise looks breathtaking here — just check out that decloaking scene!

We’ll have a full analysis of the trailer shot-by-shot further down the road — including full, uncompressed 1080p stills and video — but here’s a look at one particularly noticeable image: the contrast between CBS Digital’s presentation of McKinley Station (seen in this trailer through a shuttlecraft window) and the station’s Season 4 appearance in “Family” (remastered by the external team at Modern Video) — a definite improvement!

“Family” (Modern Video) “All Good Things…” (CBS Digital)
family-hd-005

While the finale is already presented in its original, ninety-two-minute uncut form on the Season 7 set, this single disc release will sport a crop of exclusive bonus content, including an audio commentary with writers Ronald D. Moore and Brannon Braga, a new behind-the-scenes documentary and almost seven minutes of deleted scenes.

AndronaSpeaking of deleted scenes, this trailer provides an early glimpse at the first Star Trek appearance of actress Martha Hackett — better known as Voyager villain Seska — who guested in “All Good Things…” as Androna, a Terrellian pilot who leads a fleet of ships to the Devron system to experience the anti-time anomaly’s healing effects.

The only other image of Androna ever released was in a 1997 issue of the UK’s Star Trek Magazine as part of an article covering cut footage and other deleted scenes (though her costume was auctioned off in a 2007 That’s A Wrap auction).

We’re expecting “All Good Things…” to hit shelves on December 2 in the US along with the full Season 7 release, and we’ll be sure to update you about international releases as further information becomes available.

Be on the lookout for host of articles featuring commentary, analysis, HD screencaps, and video downloads from “All Good Things…” in the coming weeks, along with our ongoing TNG Season 7 preview coverage.

div_spacer

Finally, here’s a look at the “All Good Things…” Blu-ray packaging artwork, featuring John de Lancie’s Q, ready to pass judgement on humanity:

agt-cover

Be sure to lock in your preorder using the links below — and tell us your thoughts about the new trailer in the comments below!

div_spacer

Order Star Trek:
TNG Season 7
on Blu-ray!





Order TNG's
"All Good Things..."

on Blu-ray!



REVIEW: “Star Trek: Seekers — Second Nature”

Star Trek: Seekers #1
Second Nature

By David Mack
Release Date: July 21, 2014
Pocket Books

 

From the back cover:

An all-new Star Trek series begins!

A new mission: The late twenty-third century—Starfleet’s golden age of exploration. Desperate to stay one step ahead of its rivals, the Federation sends two starships, the scout Sagittarius and the cruiser Endeavour, to plumb the secrets of the vast region known as the Taurus Reach.

A doomed race: Drawn by mysterious energy readings to a lush green world, the crew of the Sagittarius find the Tomol: a species whose members all commit ritual suicide just as they reach the cusp of adulthood.

An old foe: The crew of the Sagittarius wants to save the Tomol from their cycle of self-destruction, but first they’ll need to save themselves—from the most nefarious Klingon starship commander in history.

My thoughts:

Here it is: one of the most anticipated new Star Trek novels of the year: the first installment of the all-new series, Seekers. How does it fare?

To start with, a bit of history of Seekers. After the end of the incredibly great Vanguard series, David Mack, Dayton Ward, and Kevin Dilmore were inspired by the art of Rob Caswell, who had done a series of faux covers in the style of the old James Blish Star Trek novels, which he titled The Seekers. These covers featured an Archer-class ship, just like the U.S.S. Sagittarius from Vanguard.

At the end of the Vanguard series, the Sagittarius and the Endeavour were both sent out on missions of exploration in the Taurus Reach. These missions would serve as the backdrop for this new series, Star Trek: Seekers. Because of the inspiration his work had provided, not to mention the high quality of it, Caswell was invited to create the covers for the Seekers novels!

terrell

Seekers #1 is an exciting beginning to this new series. Bringing together characters we’re familiar with from Vanguard along with a few new faces, the story serves as an excellent re-introduction to the Sagittarius. Under the command of Captain Clark Terrell (later seen as the commanding officer of the U.S.S. Reliant in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan), the Sagittarius is unlike any of the other Starfleet vessels featured in novels or on televised Trek.

Much smaller than the larger Constitution-class starships, the Archer-class scout is only a few decks tall and features some very cramped quarters, in every sense of the word. The crew dynamic is much more laid-back than the reader might be used to. With a much smaller crew, the Sagittarius seems to boast a much more informal command structure. This leads to some interesting interactions among the crew, which some readers may find a little jarring.

The story itself is a fascinating one. We’re introduced to the Tomol, a species with a surprising dark side. Just as its members reach adulthood, they commit ritual suicide by casting themselves into a fire pit. The society teaches that this is necessary, and most of the Tomol don’t question it.

However, one Tomol resists and manages to evade being cast into the pit (with the help of some Klingon interlopers). Turning the Trek trope of “we know better than you, and your quaint beliefs are wrong” on its head, it turns out that this ritual suicide might be a good idea after all; Nimur, the Tomol who escapes the fires, undergoes a frightening metamorphosis that has some very surprising connections to a prior threat from Star Trek: Vanguard.

vanguard

Mack is a master of writing action and suspense. Near the end of the novel, when the Sagittarius is plummeting towards the planet surface, I was on the edge of my seat. Of particular note is a sequence in which Master Chief Illuci is attempting to get a critical component back on-line, and the bypass line he has rigged is only a few centimeters too short to reach the port.

I was terrified for the safety of the ship! While Mack can also write epic, sweeping stories, it is the very human struggles of the characters in his novels that provide the true drama.

Final thoughts:

A few months ago, Star Trek book editor Margaret Clark said in an interview that the reason the second Seekers novel was being released immediately after the first was because readers wouldn’t be able to stand it otherwise. After reading Second Nature, I am forced to agree.

An exciting and action-packed beginning to what looks to be an extremely promising new series, this novel earns top marks from me. I can’t wait to read the conclusion to the story in the follow-up release, Seekers #2: Point of Divergence.

– Reviewed by Literature Editor Dan Gunther

div_spacer

Order Seekers #1:
Second Nature

REVIEW: “Star Trek: The Compendium” Blu-ray Set

STID_BR_DVD_Retail

The Compendium is a (mostly) complete set of all material produced for the two JJ Abrams Star Trek films — and it should have been released a year ago, when Paramount was focused on things like the one-off “Meteor Edition” of Into Darkness, rather than offering fans a truly substantial home media release.

While the 2009 film was released as a comprehensive ‘special edition’ years ago, Trek fans were forced to purchase — at minimum — three separate copies of Star Trek Into Darkness if they wanted to get their hands on all the behind-the-scenes bonus material created for last year’s film, much to just about everyone’s dismay.

This new Compendium set does a fairly good job of rounding up all the disparate features put out in 2013, and presents them in one all-encompassing new Blu-ray release.

The Packaging

The Compendium comes in a matte-finish, DigiPack-style cardboard book that doesn’t offer much in the way of design past the embossed front cover. There’s no interior or back-cover artwork, and the set should probably have come with at least a slipcover to protect the casing.

stc-casestc-interior

Additionally, this book is about 1cm taller than standard plastic Blu-ray cases, which means you’ll need to account for the extra height in your storage plans.

stc-spine

Aside from Ultraviolet / iTunes Digital Copy codes for each movie, there’s no additional physical material included with this release.

.   .   .

The Discs

Paramount has put together a four-disc release which pulls together all material from 2009’s Star Trek three-disc special edition Blu-ray set along with the myriad features distributed across retailers for the 2013 Star Trek Into Darkness Blu-ray release. Aside from the new disc artwork, the 2009 discs are completely identical to the original release — right down to the commercial for Fringe, which has been off the air for nearly two years.

stc-discs

But for Star Trek Into Darkness, the Compendium set includes both the iTunes enhanced commentary — presented here as a ‘branching’ playback option on disc — and most of the elusive Into Darkness deleted scenes relegated to the XBOX Video release have been included as well, here on disc for the first time.

Check out our previous Into Darkness media reviews, covering all these features:

review target commentary delscenes

What’s New?

The biggest addition to the Into Darkness release is the long-awaited, shifting-aspect-ratio IMAX version of the film, previously only available in 720p as an iTunes-exclusive video download. Several scenes in the film were shot with large-format IMAX cameras, which ended up being cropped to a standard 1.78:1 aspect ratio for all other media releases.

We’ve selected a number of examples from the approximately thirty minutes of IMAX footage included in this release; while some shots simply appear to have been cropped for the theatrical release, others are reframed to center the action within the reduced frame height.

Theatrical Version vs. IMAX Version

imax01-thumb imax02-thumb imax03-thumb imax04-thumb imax05-thumb imax06-thumb imax07-thumb imax08-thumb imax09-thumb imax10-thumb imax11-thumb imax12-thumb imax13-thumb imax14-thumb imax15-thumb imax16-thumb imax17-thumb imax18-thumb imax19-thumb imax20-thumb

In addition, Paramount has also included several theatrical trailers, two new featurettes, and a full-length gag reel not available on any previously-released Blu-ray release — perhaps an attempt to sweeten the purchase a bit more for fans debating whether or not this new release is one to add to their collections.

fitting

Fitting the Future (5:03)

This new feature focuses on costume designer Michael Kaplan’s work dressing the principle and extras cast for the second outing of the rebooted Enterprise.

Much of the focus is aimed at the difficult creation of the color-coded Starfleet wetsuits seen at the beginning of the film, but time is also given to the new spacesuits worn by Khan and Kirk when they space-jump from the Enterprise, the blue-and-black uniforms of the Vengeance crew, and the various looks worn by Benedict Cumberbatch throughout the movie.

. . .

comm

Property of Starfleet (4:53)

Andy Siegel, the Star Trek films’ prop master, leads a whirlwind tour of several Into Darkness props, including the newly-designed tricorder, Khan’s portable transporter unit (inspired by a frequently-used vacuum cleaner), Spock’s volcano ‘ice cube’ machine, Khan’s giant gun used on Kronos, Klingon disruptors, and the enormous Section 31 photon torpedo device.

The cast and crew speak at length about the realism and practicality of having physical props in such a futuristic environment, and how keeping things ‘grounded’ allows the audience (and actors) to connect with the world of the 23rd Century.

. . .

spock-gag

Gag Reel (5:48)

This lengthy blooper video covers on-set goofing around from all aspects of the shoot, from fight scene mishaps to prop malfunctions to loads of laughing, dancing, and general foolishness from just about all of the cast and crew. While somewhat standard gag reel fare, this one is without any ‘set up’ bloopers or practical jokes, like the “Neutron Cream” prank seen in the “Safety First” Best Buy featurette.

What’s Missing?

Perhaps the most controversial “missing piece” to this collection is the exclusion of the 3D IMAX edition of Star Trek Into Darkness. While the 3D market may represent a small portion of overall consumer purchases, this version of the movie is one that should be available for those 3D aficionados who which to experience the most immersive version of the film possible.

imax3d

There are also a few other bits still left out for unknown reasons, including:

div_spacer

 

Finally, we have confirmed that The Compendium is going to be a North America-only release, at least for the foreseeable future. Like other Paramount releases, however, this is a region-free set, so international shoppers can feel free to import the Blu-ray set from either of the Amazon links below.

Order Star Trek:
The Compendium
on Blu-ray today!


Order Star Trek Into Darkness on 3D Blu-ray today!



REVIEW: “Star Trek: TNG — The Light Fantastic”

Star Trek: TNG
The Light Fantastic
By Jeffrey Lang
Release Date: June 24, 2014
Pocket Books

 

From the back cover:

He was perhaps the ultimate human achievement: a sentient artificial life-form—self-aware, self-determining, possessing a mind and a body far surpassing that of his makers, and imbued with the potential to evolve beyond the scope of his programming.

And then Data was destroyed.

Four years later, Data’s creator, Noonien Soong, sacrificed his life and resurrected his android son, who in turn revived the positronic brain of his own artificial daughter, Lal. Having resigned his commission, the former Starfleet officer now works to make his way on an alien world, while also coming to grips with the very human notion of wanting versus having a child.

But complicating Data’s new life is an unexpected nemesis from years ago on the U.S.S. Enterprise—the holographic master criminal Professor James Moriarty. Long believed to be imprisoned in a memory solid, Moriarty has created a siphon into the “real” world as a being of light and thought. Moriarty wants the solid form that he was once told he could never have, and seeks to manipulate Data into finding another android body for him to permanently inhabit . . . even if it means that is Data himself.

Returning to the story begun in the novel Immortal Coil and continuing in the bestselling Cold Equations trilogy, this is the next fascinating chapter in the artificial life of one of Star Trek’s most enduring characters.

My thoughts:

I had a great many thoughts while reading this novel. Regular followers of my reviews will remember than I very much enjoyed the books that preceded this one in the telling of Data’s story: Jeffrey Lang’s own Immortal Coil, as well as the Cold Equations trilogy by David Mack that finally returned Data to the land of the living.

Is it Data, though?

That’s the question I kept asking myself while reading The Light Fantastic. And as troubling as this may be, the answer I was forced to come to was no… and yes. A lot of the elements that made Data who he is are there: the sometimes child-like innocence shows through occasionally, but it is definitely tempered by an “edge” that his character didn’t have before.

soong

As user “Deranged Nasat” put it on TrekBBS’s Trek Literature board, “Data 2.0 is both greatly familiar and alarmingly unpredictable.” This is not exactly the Data we’ve come to know and love, but something new… but still someone who is familiar. And Jeffrey Lang is able to craft his voice perfectly.

The characters in this novel are a real treat to read about. The friendship between Data and LaForge has certainly changed, but still retains many of the elements of the close relationship they had in TNG. And kudos to Mr. Lang for addressing the minor discontinuity between David McIntee’s novel Indistinguishable From Magic and the later TNG novels with regards to LaForge’s relationship(s). Polyamory (or at least open relationships) seems to be a topic that is being explored lately.

Other characters in the novel such as Lal, Alice, Shakti, and Albert Lee were welcome additions, and each had unique moments that were a pleasure to read. The primary antagonist, Moriarty, and his consort, the Countess Regina Bartholomew, were likewise compelling. Moriarty has the potential to be a very cliched villain, and it is the character’s seeming awareness of this that contributes to how well he works in the story.

moriarty

The continuity connections in this novel are nothing short of spectacular. As with his earlier entry, Immortal Coil, Lang mines the entirety of Trek history for ties to his story, drawing from the original series, The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, and Voyager.

I particularly enjoyed the ending of this story. Both ambiguous and sowing the seeds for further adventures, the ending left me excited for further adventures with Data and even, perhaps, Moriarty.

Final thoughts:

In an interview on Trek.fm’s Literary Treks podcast (an interview in which I had the privilege of taking part), Jeffrey Lang said that Margaret Clark — editor of the Trek literature line at Pocket Books — called Lang’s story a “nice dessert” after the seriousness of The Fall and its political intrigue and machinations. I would have to agree.

While the threat in The Light Fantastic is quite real, the story felt like a much-needed bit of lighter fare, and one that I enjoyed immensely. In my opinion, The Light Fantastic is the top Trek novel of the year (so far… we still have Seekers on the way, not to mention another Voyager entry from the amazing Kirsten Beyer!)

Top marks for this one from me. I look forward to seeing many more Jeffrey Lang novels to come!

– Reviewed by Literature Editor Dan Gunther

div_spacer

Order Star Trek TNG:
The Light Fantastic

Trek Comics Review #36: ‘The Q Gambit’ (Part 2)

Our Trek Comics editor Patrick Hayes is back with a review of this month’s issue of IDW Publishing’s Star Trek ongoing comic series: the second chapter of “The Q Gambit,” a new six-part saga.

trek36-cover

A terrific pair of cover for readers to transport into their collections. Tony Shasteen, this book’s interior artist and colorist, has created this month’s regular cover. Going from closest to farthest, Sisko, Kirk, and Spock’s busts have been placed before Deep Space 9 with the wormhole opening gloriously behind them. These characters look fantastic and the coloring is great, even if there are some lens flares occurring.  Grade: A.

The photo cover is taken from an episode of Star Trek: Voyager showing John de Lancie as the iconic Q garbed in a Starfleet uniform. You know you’re a Trek fan if just seeing this character makes your heart race at the possibilities his appearance brings, and there was a big one that ended last month’s issue.  Grade: A+.

trek36-story

This second chapter in “The Q Gambit” by Mike Johnson opens where it dramatically left off last month: the Enterprise at the front door of Deep Space 9. Kirk orders a Red Alert, not knowing where they are, as weapons lock on the ship. Attacked by three very familiar looking ships, the Enterprise tries to escape.

Under fire and, suddenly, operating only on impulse engines, Q appears behind Kirk to say, “From this point on, whatever happens next is completely out of my control… but still very much within yours. Try to make good decisions. I’ll excuse myself for a moment. Company’s coming.” His disappearance marks the arrival of three individuals beaming aboard.

This is a fantastic story. On Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, the crew went into the past in the episode “Trials and Tribble-ations.” Now the past has come to the future and it’s not the optimistic future fans are used to seeing. The final words at the bottom of Page 6 turn everything every fan knows about the franchise upside down. A conversation begins on Page 9 with a classic Trek villain in one of the most famous sets of DS9.

Johnson does an amazing job with this character’s voice whose dialogue is impossible not to hear in the voice of the actor that played this role. There is a hint of troubles to come for a specific group from the Enterprise on Page 14, but future issues will have to reveal their fate.

Things take a triumphant turn on Page 16 and the reveal on Page 17 was picture perfect. A new setting creates an opportunity to give some backstory to our crew’s current dilemma and Page 22 is a jaw-dropper of a reveal and tease. I really, really want to see more of this final location and have the Enterprise crew go here. This was a fantastic chapter.  Grade: A+.

trek36-art

The illustrations and colors are by Tony Shasteen. Every character in this issue is photorealistic. It is great to see John de Lancie’s Q talking to Chris Pine’s Kirk. The arrival of the threesome on Page 5 made my heart leap because they are one of my favorite post-Roddenberry aliens. When said invaders use their weapons on Page 6 it’s a shocking moment. Rarely in any Star Trek series did weapons fire look so brutal.

Making me even happier is the likeness of the individual that appears on Page 9. I love this character and was ecstatic to see this person look so good. The close-up at the bottom of the same page perfectly mirrors the dialogue the character is saying. The entire scene between Kirk and this person comes off as lost scene from the television series. Sending me over the top for this individual is the glorious second panel on 16.

The settings were, again, mixed. Many of the backgrounds, on the Enterprise and in other places, are photoscans. They are blurry blobs of shapes that draw attention to their poor quality. However, Shasteen uses color to move readers’ eyes from these scanned images to focus on objects in the foreground. For example, Page 5 uses red to fill and disguise and a sickly yellow transporter effect to distort the backgrounds. It’s a smart use of coloring, but I can still see the smudged photos.

My grade would be higher if the backgrounds were drawn.  Grade: B+.

trek36-letters

Yells, sound effects, dialogue, and a “To Be Continued!” come courtesy Neil Uyetake. His highpoint is the transporter sound effects, which I can never get enough of.  Grade: A-.

35covers-thumb

Bottom line:
This second chapter of “The Q Gambit” is an incredible story with art that just falls short of perfection.  Grade: A-.

– Reviewed by Comics Editor Patrick Hayes

div_spacer

trek36-small Order Star Trek #36:
The Q Gambit, Part 2 

Trek Comics Review: ‘City on the Edge of Forever’ #2

Our Trek Comics editor Patrick Hayes has his review of IDW Publishing’s second City on the Edge of Forever comic adaptation, based on writer Harlan Ellison’s original teleplay.

city2_cover

Juan Ortiz provides the artwork for the regular cover. Kirk and Spock look through the iconic portal and outside of its entrance is a sweet skyline from Earth’s past. Oritz continues to dazzle with his interpretations of classic Trek. It makes me think of an Andy Warhol print. I may be getting ahead of myself, but my fingers are crossed that this image will become a T-shirt or print in the future.  Grade: A.

The subscription cover is by Paul Shipper, showing bust shots of Kirk and Spock against a brightly colored yellow and violet starfield. Nice renderings of both characters, reminding me of the artwork of Keith Birdsong.  Grade: A+.

city2_story

Picking right up from last issue, Beckwith has gone through the portal and changed time. So drastic is the change, the Guardians leave the Enterprise crew saying, “The machines of the ancients are registering traumas in time. We must return.” Return where? That’s a question that’s beyond the scope of any human. After their disappearance, Kirk quickly realizes they have to go back to their ship.

Wisely, Kirk has the security team beam up first, while he, Spock, and Rand beam up seconds later. What could possibly go wrong when the red shirts are separated from the command crew?

What they find in space will surprise readers. This wasn’t in the aired episode, so this is new territory for those who haven’t read Harlan Ellison’s original teleplay. Scott and David Tipton are doing a bang-up job on this adaptation. I love that a supporting character starts the action on Page 6 and engages in fisticuffs on Page 7. Back on the planet, the Guardians have returned to speak with Kirk and Spock, having a wonderfully dismissive line at the bottom of Page 9.

The speech given on Page 16, sadly, is reminiscent of words currently being said in America, creating an eerie “What have we learned?” moment in the story. I was shocked by Kirk’s solution for a speedy escape on Page 19; I would have behaved as the onlookers do at such an exhibition.

I’ve seen this episode countless times and read the screenplay twice, yet this is completely fresh in this format.  Grade: A.

city2_art

This book is gorgeous on every page. J.K. Woodward does an exceptional job on the characters’ faces: Kirk’s emotions are stellar, portrayed well on several pages; you can really feel the frustration rushing out of him. My favorite image is on Page 4, with the captain giving a flying leap — elbow first — into a foe. How could a Trek fan not love this pose? Spock is great and Rand is fantastic throughout the book.

The settings are wonderful, with the icy world of the Guardians giving The Empire Strikes Back’s Hoth a run for its money. The the orbiting ship is excellent, and Earth’s past is a blast (with some familiar names appearing on businesses). Page 14 has a transition that could have been very awkward. There are several ways this could have been accomplished but what Woodward has done is the perfect way to pay homage to the effects of the original series, yet make it look modern. Really, really well done. This transition has a great ending at the bottom of Page 15, with Spock looking just awesome.

When things get hostile with the natives, Woodward smartly tilts the perspective in several ways. Page 18 begins with a great shot looking upward at some antagonists. The next panel is almost at a 45 degree angle for the action that occurs, which makes what transpires more intense. The final two pages continue these askew views, making the action dynamic.

I also have to draw attention to the coloring. The explosions and sounds that begin on 4 are powerful because of their hues and Page 13 made me think of the classic poster for Star Trek: The Motion Picture. Woodward has brought his ‘A’ game to this book.  Grade: A.

city2_letters

I do not envy letterer Neil Uyetake’s job on this book. I would be continually second-guessing myself as to what parts of Woodward’s art I should “cover” with dialogue balloons and sounds. Thankfully, it’s not my job, and Uyetake expertly places the text so that no art is drowning in wordage.

I was impressed with the special font employed for the Guardians’ speech which reinforces their aged appearance.  Grade: A.

city-covers-thumb

Bottom line: Star Trek. Harlan Ellison. The Tipton brothers. J.K. Woodward. Neil Uyetake. IDW. The ingredients couldn’t be better for a perfect feast. Dig in!  Grade: A.

– Reviewed by Comics Editor Patrick Hayes

div_spacer

city2_small Order Harlan Ellison’s
City on the Edge of Forever #2

Death Is Irrelevant: TNG & “The Best of Both Worlds”

Dissecting the Power and Impact of
One of Star Trek’s Most Influential Episodes

by Rob Heyman for TrekCore.com

div_spacer

Twenty-four years ago this month, a grueling summer-long wait was about to come to end. Fans of Star Trek: The Next Generation were about the find out if Picard — captured and transformed by the Borg in the thrilling two-part episode “The Best of Both Worlds” — was going to be destroyed by the Enterprise.

For those of us around at the time who watched “The Best of Both Worlds” on television (and saved it for endless rewatching on VHS), the season premier on September 24, 1990, could not come fast enough.

bobw1

Part One of “The Best of Both Worlds” is widely celebrated as the one of the best episodes of Star Trek – at the very least, the best of The Next Generation. But what is it about this episode that made it so memorable among fans and a noted achievement among critics. It even seemed like The Next Generation itself could not escape the long shadow of this episode in the years that followed, never quite able to deliver another Borg episode — or another cliffhanger for that matter — with the same fresh spirit and adrenaline.

In retrospect, the success of the Borg finale for Season Three can be attributed to good timing, a writing and production staff hitting its creative stride, and a hunger for a new Borg episode after their memorable “Q Who” appearance in Season Two. Composer Ron Jones’ propulsive musical score must be mentioned here as well with a king-sized asterisk.

It’s an astonishing achievement in television scoring and, I would argue, a large factor in the finale’s overall success. When I first saw the finale in the summer of 1990, I didn’t just watch it – I “heard” it. It became a cinematic experience, and when the orchestra launches into a bombastic frenzy in those final seconds after Riker orders Worf to fire, I knew I had just witnessed something very special.

bobw2

After a total of three exciting episodes committed to Picard’s abduction (if you count the unofficial third part “Family”), it was easy to forget that Star Trek was about more than just the Borg. It didn’t help that Picard ended “The Best of Both Worlds, Part II” in his ready room casting a troubled stare out the window.

Was he telling us that he really wasn’t cured of his experience? Or was that look intended to communicate his fears that the Borg are still out there and that their story isn’t over? At the time, I saw it more as an omen of things to come, as I’m sure many fans did – an echo of the creep ending of “Conspiracy” from Season One. As a result, everything after “Family” just felt like filler until that next, inevitable Borg episode.

One has to wonder how The Next Generation would have played out had it not had “The Best of Both Worlds.” The cliffhanger certainly attracted many new fans and garnered the series widespread acclaim. Personally, the two episodes that sold me best on The Next Generation were “Yesterday’s Enterprise and “Hollow Pursuits,” both also from the third season. “Tin Man” is another terrific installment from that season.

With so many stand-out shows that year, it’s likely The Next Generation would have turned out just fine without the Borg’s return in the season finale. The Next Generation was on a hot streak, and the original series, which had loomed so large over the show those first few seasons, was suddenly a distant memory.

bobw3

With the incredible success of “The Best of Both Worlds,” you’d expect the producers to have kept the momentum going in the fourth season with a lot more action-adventure. Instead, they chose to go personal, stocking many of the season’s early episodes with inexpensive family stories and “bottle” shows. Even the music, which had made minor celebrities of Ron Jones and Dennis McCarthy after Season Three, became increasingly more muted and lifeless – owing in no small part to executive producer Rick Berman’s mind-boggling mandate to keep the music as low-key as possible.

When Ron Jones was fired at the end of Season Four, it was clear that a chapter had come to an end and that there would probably never be another “Best of Both Worlds.” After all, what was a Borg episode without Ron Jones? The themes he crafted in “Q Who” were expanded to incredible effect in “The Best of Both Worlds.” I often wonder how he would have played with these themes had he been around to score the more-intimate “I Borg” in Season Five.

It’s not entirely fair to hand all the credit for “The Best of Both Worlds” to Ron Jones. Part One, in particular, was also a very well-written story featuring some long-overdue character conflict. Casting Elizabeth Dennehy as Riker’s adversary was a coup, and the special effects were top-notch, especially for the time. It was definitely a package achievement. Jones just gave it that extra, satisfying kick.

bobw4

For its remaining three seasons, The Next Generation tried to strike a balance among family drama, action-adventure, and “weird shit” with mixed success. When we finally get another real Borg adventure, it comes in the form of another two-part episode called “Descent,” which played like a cheap copy of “The Best of Both Worlds” with little of the same excitement.

In truth, “Descent” more closely echoes first season’s “The Arsenal of Freedom,” with Crusher standing in for Geordi this time in a fish-out-of-water command turn. Whereas in “Arsenal,” you can almost see the sweat pouring down Geordi’s face, Crusher’s stab at the big chair is almost too easy, even with the contrived tension between two bridge officers. Jay Chattaway does get a chance to loosen up the score a bit for, especially in Part Two, but it’s certainly not on par with what Jones gave us for “The Best of Both Worlds.”

The Borg, as we all know, would return time again for the news series and movies. It’s a testament to the achievements of “Q Who” and “The Best of Both Worlds” that these villains enjoyed such longevity. For itself, “The Best of Both Worlds” marked a moment in time – and what a moment it was! Fans may forever debate the best episode of The Next Generation, but I don’t think it can be argued that “The Best of Both Worlds” was the moment when the new series truly arrived and asked to be finally taken seriously.

“Star Trek: The Compendium” Blu-ray Rebate Details

The “Star Trek: The Compendium” Blu-ray release is just a few weeks away, and Paramount Home Entertainment today unveiled the rumored rebate program for fans who previously purchased either Star Trek  or Star Trek Into Darkness on Blu-ray in their initial releases.

rebate
All one must do is visit StarTrekMovie.com/Rebate and complete a form, which requires the UPC barcode number of a purchased Star Trek or Star Trek Into Darkness Blu-ray set along with the “Compendium” UPC barcode number — and a “Compendium” receipt of purchase.

trek-compendium

To qualify, fans must purchase the “Compendium” set between September 9 and October 31, and must submit the form by mail to Paramount by November 30.

This program is only available to residents of the United States.
DVD purchases are not eligible for this program.

div_spacer

Order Star Trek:
The Compendium
on Blu-ray today!


Order Star Trek Into Darkness on 3D Blu-ray today!



Interview with Preston Neal Jones, Author/Editor of “Return to Tomorrow: The Filming of Star Trek: TMP”

return-header

Last month, a long-rumored book chronicling the troubled production of Star Trek: The Motion Picture was finally announced from Creature Features Publishing: Return to Tomorrow – The Filming of Star Trek: The Motion Picture, by Preston Neal Jones.

Creature Features Publishing presents one of the great, legendary “long lost” Making-Of movie books: Return to Tomorrow: The Filming of Star Trek: The Motion Picture by Preston Neal Jones. This is a stunningly detailed and candid oral history going behind the scenes of one of the most famous films not only in Star Trek but science fiction and cinema history.

In 1979, Preston Neal Jones was given unparalleled access to the cast and creators of Star Trek: The Motion Picture for what was intended to be a cover story for Cinefantastique magazine. Owing to the late completion of the film and ambitious scope of the manuscript, it was never published—until now. This book is a priceless time capsule, a 672-page oral history in the words of 60 of the film’s cast and creators, interviewed as the film was being prepared for release—and nobody had any idea if it would succeed or even be finished on time.

From the stars (William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy and the entire cast) to the filmmakers (Gene Roddenberry, Robert Wise) to the brilliant visual effect artists, illustrators, model builders and technicians who realized the 23rd century on screen (costumes, sets, props, models, music, sound FX and more), no aspect of the film’s creation is overlooked. The entire manuscript has been laboriously fact-checked and prepared for modern publication, while retaining all of the candid comments from 35 years ago. The gorgeous cover art is the original painting by Roger Stine intended for Cinefantastique, courtesy the Daren R. Dochterman Collection.

Go behind the scenes of this pivotal sci-fi masterwork and hear the unvarnished, uncensored truth of how it was created. Strictly limited to 1,000 copies, this mammoth trade paperback is available for pre-order now and ship in October. The first 100 copies will come hand-signed by the author, so order your copy today!

Our Trek literature editor Dan Gunther caught up with Preston Neal Jones about the development of this book, and just why it took more than three decades for it to arrive in print.

div_spacer

TREKCORE: The Motion Picture is viewed by many Star Trek fans as a flawed piece, although it is remembered by many others with fondness. Why do you think this film has been regarded this way?

Preston Neal Jones: Well, in my experience, I don’t think those two views of the film are mutually exclusive, necessarily. What work of art doesn’t have its flaws? So, it’s possible to perceive flaws in a movie — always a personally subjective procedure, of course — and still have a fondness for it, warts and all. It becomes a question of degrees whether an individual thinks The Motion Picture overall (or any other movie) succeeds or fails when its perceived faults are weighed against its perceived virtues.

Actually, in the short time since we announced Return to Tomorrow, it’s been fascinating for me to read some of the online commentary, ranging across both of those two extremes you’ve described. In between them, you’ve also got people who found fault with the original picture who nevertheless feel that a lot of those problems were corrected in the director’s cut. And then, on the other hand, there are folks who like the 1979 version so much that they still prefer it to the one with Mr. Wise’s long-hoped-for revisions. It takes all kinds to make a galaxy.

rtt-cover

TREKCORE: The Motion Picture was released thirty-five years ago. Why did it take so long for this book to come to print?

PNJ: That’s a long story — or at least, an awful lot of short stories all adding up to one long gestation period. This project was originally planned to be a special double-size issue of the late, lamented Cinefantastique magazine, similar to ones they had brought out to celebrate Star Wars and Close Encounters of the Third Kind. For various professional and personal reasons, my opus took longer to complete than those other two, yet the Cinefantastique editor still promised that he was going to publish the Star Trek issue — but in the end, he never did.

Over the years, I tried to get it launched as a book, and my first port of call was naturally Pocket Books, the publisher authorized by Paramount to do any and all Star Trek books. Now, my book was never intended to be a muckraker, but it was an honest account of how Star Trek ran into difficulties — as every movie does, let’s face it — during its long production history. When I sent a sample of the first 100 pages or so to the Pocket Books editor assigned to Star Trek, he personally loved it, but he didn’t think the studio would go for publishing such a non-puffery piece about the film. So that was that.

In my book, I go into the whole back story of trying to find a home for Return to Tomorrow, including my efforts to have it be released an unofficial Trek publication, but I don’t think I included any talk about Pocket Books, so you’ve got a bit of an exclusive there. In any event, there’s a much more detailed answer contained in the introduction to my book –and in the meantime, anyone who’d like to learn a little more about Return to Tomorrow’s birth pangs can always read the Lost Books section at Steve Roby’s Starfleet Library website.

cfq

TREKCORE: What was the most memorable moment you had during the process of putting this book together?

PNJ: Oh, gosh, you don’t really think I can keep it down to just one, do you? In the first place, when Cinefantastique’s Fred Clarke initially offered me the gig, I got excited simply at the prospect of getting to meet three of my heroes: Robert Wise, Isaac Asimov, and Jerry Goldsmith. And suffice it to say that I was not disappointed when I conducted all three of those interviews. I have special memories, some humorous and some touching, connected with most of my encounters with the original TV cast.

You may remember, for instance, that Mr. Shatner had worked hard to get himself back into (space)shipshape for the film, and he was still maintaining his health regimen while promoting it all over the place. Our conversation took place at one of his favorite restaurants, and I’m still tickled recalling how he encouraged me to order a fantastically sinful dessert of which he was very fond — the waiter automatically knew what it would be from serving him on previous occasions — and then, when the grand concoction arrived, Captain Kirk dipped his fork into it so that he could enjoy just one little bite.

And I’m still very touched whenever I recall the warmth of Mr. Kelley when we had our conversation at the Paramount lot. After that, we kept in touch a few times on the phone, which was not typical of most of my interviewees, and I can still hear him asking me, “So, how’s everything in your young life?” He was also very generous in giving me permission to quote from a poem he had written, “The Big Bird’s Dream,” all about Roddenberry and the show, which you’ll find sprinkled throughout the early portion of Return to Tomorrow as a way of introducing each of his fellow actors.

Getting to walk onto the Enterprise set — which was surprisingly small — was a treat, of course. So was meeting and talking with the late Mark Lenard, and thanking him for his work, long before Star Trek, on a wonderful CBS special called Americans: A Portrait in Verses he’d done with James Whitmore and a lot of other fine actors. And I treasure sitting down with Mr.Goldsmith in his home studio to listen to the tape — which had just arrived in the mail that day — of his first version of the Enterprise drydock flyby, before Mr. Wise had insisted that he revise it, which led to the now-famous main title theme.

kirk-scotty

TREKCORE: Many fans have heard of the troubles that The Motion Picture went through during the making of the film. What was one incident that stood out to you as being particularly difficult?

PNJ: Where to begin? I have to say that, when the picture was finally given the green-light at Paramount after years of neglect, the one thing that was responsible for causing more problems than anything else was the studio’s painting themselves into a corner by committing to a fixed release date of December 7, 1979. From that one Pandora’s box emerged a whole slew of furies and demons, starting with rushing into production without a finished script, and culminating in the pressure — after the first FX team was let go — of having to hire two new FX teams to accomplish two year’s work in one year’s time.

That release deadline was just a real killer, seven ways from Sunday. Both Wise and Roddenberry begged the studio to grant them a reprieve, but they were completely stonewalled by the powers at Paramount, who stood to lose a gazillion bucks if they couldn’t deliver The Motion Picture to the theaters on time. Which they almost didn’t, as the last shot wasn’t filmed and inserted into the movie until just a few days before the Washington, DC, gala premiere at NASA.

Incidentally, as sort of a running commentary, I have section headings throughout the book which are direct quotes from the film’s dialogue. Perhaps the most meaningful of all, encapsulating the entire saga, is, “READY OR NOT, SHE LAUNCHES.”

wise

TREKCORE: One exciting aspect of this book is the fact that the interviews and accounts all come from the time of filming, rather than being reminiscences of the players long after the events it chronicles. What was it like to actually be on set with the producers and performers of The Motion Picture?

PNJ: Well, it was certainly a different experience than the one I’d had researching my first book about The Night of the Hunter, for which I conducted about ten or twelve interviews with a few key cast and crew members who were recollecting work experiences they’d shared decades previously. With Star Trek, you had some sixty people, many of them still licking their wounds from the heat of battle.

But I need to clarify one point: there was a lot of filming going on when I started, but it was all post-production. When I was first given the Cinefantastique assignment, principal photography had already been completed. Naturally, it was still vivid in everybody’s memory, but I was not on the soundstage while it was going on, and only got to tour the Enterprise sets when they were empty. So, while I was chatting amiably with actors, technicians, executives and craftspeople about their just-completed work on The Motion Picture, there was a vast contingent of artists, designers, modelers and photographers racing desperately around the clock to finish the film on time, and many of these people couldn’t sit down and talk with me until after their mighty labors were in the can.

That said, it was a fantastic experience getting to know all these great people while discussing their work and struggles. The whole thing was like a doctorate crash course in major movie-making. And the result of all that, I really feel, is a book which records a big studio Hollywood production in more detail than any book has ever been able to do before.

bridge

TREKCORE: Given the history of Star Trek both before and after The Motion Picture, how do you feel about its place in that history?

PNJ: That’s pretty clear, it seems to me. Whatever one thinks about TMP’s intrinsic quality, regardless of that whole controversy, there can’t be any doubt that without it, there wouldn’t be any history of Star Trek after the second cancellation of the NBC TV series, except for merchandising, cartoons, and, of course, conventions. Whatever it was which finally persuaded Paramount to revive Star Trek — and of course, a great deal of my book goes into all that — it was the ultimate product of that decision which finally proved beyond any doubt in the studio executive offices what Gene Roddenberry and so many fans already knew, that there were a hell of a lot of people out there with money in their pockets who were thrilled to spend it seeing a Star Trek feature.

Paramount had been sitting on a gold mine all those years, and now they finally started digging, and of course they haven’t stopped yet.

TREKCORE: Now that so much time has passed since the release of The Motion Picture, how do you feel about finally being able to tell the story behind the film?

PNJ: Nothing but happy, naturally — and particularly grateful to the good people at Creature Features who have turned out to be my angels at last. Of course, I’m also anxious to see how the book will be received after all these years, by film buffs, scholars and critics, surely, but most of all by the readership which it was always intended specifically to please — the Trekkers.

I’m hoping they’ll feel it was worth the long, patient wait.

Preston Neal Jones’ first excursion into cinematic oral history, “James Whale Remembered,” appeared in Forrest J Ackerman’s original Famous Monsters of Filmland. His first book, Heaven and Hell to Play With: The Filming of The Night of the Hunter, was hailed as one of the finest works of its kind and earned the Rondo Award for Book of the Year from the Classic Horror Film Board. Jones’ other writings have appeared in periodicals as disparate as Cinefantastique and American Art Review.

Active in the film/TV industry, he has served variously as creative advertising executive, script analyst and production assistant; introduced film screenings at American Cinematheque and the Los Angeles Film School; and contributed entries to Groves’ New Dictionary of Music and Musicians and The St. James Encyclopedia of Popular Culture. Jones’ liner notes have graced modern-day record- ings of music from such Golden Age film composers as Alfred Newman, Hans J. Salter and Frank Skinner.

At UCLA, Jones has lectured on the subject of film music, and at Roanoke College in Virginia (where he was writer in residence) he taught on the topics of The Night of the Hunter and Star Trek: The Motion Picture.

div_spacer

return-small Pre-order Return to Tomorrow – The Filming of
Star Trek: The Motion Picture
 today!
CFLogo

Trek Comics Review: New Visions #2

Our Trek Comics editor Patrick Hayes returns with a review of this month’s issue of IDW Publishing’s Star Trek photobook comic series New Visions.

nv2_cover

The Enterprise is aflame as it plummets to some unseemly fate, long before the events of Star Trek III: The Search for Spock. Surrounding this frightening image are snapshots of Kirk, McCoy, Spock, and Scotty looking worried. Yes, even Spock looks concerned.

In the upper right corner is a shot of the bridge crew under harsh yellow-red light, an obvious effect of the heat radiating through the ship’s shields. A small rectangular box teases an extra story featuring Janice Rand.

As excited as I am by the dramatic imagery of this cover by John Byrne, the chance to read a story that focuses on this “gone too soon” character has me anxious to see what Mr. Byrne has in store for her.  Grade: A.

nv2_story

Time’s Echo opens with Deep Space Monitor Station 18’s staff trying to convince Commander Resnick to contact the Enterprise, as they’ve found a very confusing message coming from a very confusing location. The flagship of the Federation arrives and Kirk, McCoy, Spock, Scotty, and Uhura get to work trying to make sense of the message. This premise quickly blossoms into something beyond what the characters or readers would expect.

John Byrne boldly goes where no writer has gone before. Just when you think you’ve seen and read it all for Star Trek, and, yes, I have those moments, he makes this franchise shine. Having not watched an original series episode in months, this book makes me realize how much I enjoy Kirk working out a problem with his command crew.

Hearing Sulu and McCoy chime in after Spock’s analysis, Page 8, was something that could have gone on longer and it would have pleased me to no end. The initial discovery on Page 12 won’t surprise any fan, but what is slowly revealed to have occurred is gold. Things take a surprising turn on 18, and escalate in the fifth panel on 19. There is a slick transition between the second and third panels on 21 that introduces an individual that takes the story in a new direction.

The reveal on 31 is great; it had me cheering. I admit to being nervous at the action that begins at the bottom of 35 and, once again, Byrne switches the danger to something else entirely on Page 38. This is what I love about this story: it doesn’t settle for the predictable thrills. It does what all stories should do–keep readers wondering what’s next for our heroes. After reading Star Trek stories in various media over several decades it’s such a pleasure to get something new that’s so good.

And speaking of new, there is a short story focusing on Rand titled “Sweet Sorrow.” I cannot reveal any part of it without ruining it, but if you’re a Trek fan this is must reading. Two famous supporting crew members appear that are worth the price of the cover alone. The final page will make your heart skip a beat.  Grade: A+.

nv2_art

The entire photonovel is composed of captured and composite images from original series episodes. There are also several new characters. At least, I believe they’re new. I can’t recall ever seeing Resnick before, or the female in the fourth panel on Page 1. If these characters are new, I would love to know who the actors are that John Byrne got to pose for this story. It’s exciting to think that present day actors can be in classic Trek.

The original crew has been brought to life perfectly for the scenes they’re performing in: I love Sulu’s pose on Page 8, panel four; McCoy in panel five of Page 22; 31’s reveal; Chekov at the bottom of 38; and Kirk’s final shot, matching the dialogue beautifully.

There are also several new settings that Byrne had to create for this tale. The Deep Space Monitor Station looks completely in line with anything that would have appeared on the television series. Page 7’s exterior shot is amazing, with just enough threat in its look. The computer graphic at the top of 11 was spot on 1960’s futuristic.

The interior on 21 was devastating, and took a fun turn on 24. The Enterprise burning up will have any Trek fan breathing quickly. The Rand story had me gasping on Pages 41 and 43. Page 44 has probably the most powerful nine panels ever created for a Trek book.

Finally, regarding the lettering — dialogue, the classic opening introduction, the Captain’s log, and key sounds are delivered in fine fashion by John Byrne.  Grade: A+.

nv2_cover_full

Bottom line:
With Time’s Echo, this series continues to be the best thing to happen to Star Trek since the original crew began to make films. Another lost episode to remind everyone why Star Trek endures. Highest possible recommendation.  Grade: A+.

– Reviewed by Comics Editor Patrick Hayes

div_spacer

notime-cover Order New Visions #2:
Time’s Echo