Home Blog Page 292

TrekCore YouTube Channel Offline [We’re back!]

64

NOVEMBER 14: We’re back online!

CBS has been very helpful in resolving the issues that have affected the channel over the last few weeks, and have retracted the copyright strikes they issued which caused the YouTube downtime.

We’ll have some more information in the coming weeks, but for now, go watch some of those great Blu-ray comparison videos you’ve been missing!

div_spacer

yt-header

We were dismayed to learn this morning that our heavily-followed TrekCoreVideo YouTube channel was taken offline due to several new copyright claims against our popular SD-to-HD Star Trek Blu-ray comparison videos.

This unexpected takedown was certainly a surprising turn of events, after we’ve spent so much time working with CBS to spread the word about the Next Generation and Enterprise Blu-ray projects, and have given our best effort to highlight the amazing work by the restoration team at CBS Digital over the last three years.

tweet1

CBS has been aware of our comparison videos and has offered their support by sharing and publicizing them through their own social media channels — something that makes this takedown even more surprising.

At present, we expect our video services to be offline for at least the next several weeks as we investigate this situation, and we will continue to update our readers on this ongoing issue as possible.

We’ve highlighted some of our favorite comments below; we encourage you to share your feedback as well!

div_spacer

yt-quotes

Trek Comics Review #37: ‘The Q Gambit’ (Part 3)

Our Trek Comics editor Patrick Hayes is back with a review of this month’s issue of IDW Publishing’s Star Trek comic series: the third chapter of “The Q Gambit,” an ongoing six-part saga.

37cover

The first of two covers is by interior artist Tony Shasteen. Engineer Q is farthest from the reader, striking a passive bust-like pose. Before him looking grandiose is Chancellor Worf. Flying before both zips the Defiant, seemingly on a missing to protect the three individuals on the planet below: McCoy, Spock, and Kira, who’s wearing some new togs while firing a blaster.

All look good save the Doctor, who resembles a primate. The coloring is also well done, with yellow and orange being used strikingly.  Grade: A.

The ohoto cover is an image from Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, of the always photogenic Worf as played by Michael Dorn. He looks exceptional, and, yes, when didn’t he? The intensity of his eyes remind fans why Klingons are not to be taken for granted, and foreshadows events within.  Grade: A+.

37story

The third chapter of “The Q Gambit,” written by Mike Johnson, opens with the Defiant landing in San Francisco, carrying Kirk, Sisko, Odo, Scotty, and Uhura. The next three pages are a quick summary of how history has changed since the Enterprise disappeared almost one hundred years ago.

The arrival of Dominion changed the balance of power in the quadrant, and Earth fell to the Klingons. Page 4 ends the history lesson with Sisko giving a patented Federation rah-rah speech. And, yes, I got goosebumps. The arrival of three individuals, with one being very familiar, ends the humans’ conversation.

Meanwhile on Bajor, the science divisions of the Enterprise, with McCoy and Spock being the focus, discover life under Cardassians rule. The reveal at the end of Page 8 made my heart sing — I love this individual and this character’s dialogue and actions are gold. Speaking of this rare metal, another familiar face appears on 17, making another fantastic character addition to this story.

There is a lot to love in this story: Earth under Klingon rule, the appearances of many character from Deep Space Nine, McCoy’s wisecracks (especially at the bottom of Page 15), the reappearance of Q to tease the crew, and a great cliffhanger.

Johnson has got the beats of this story down to a science, as every other page reveals a classic character or conflict to confound the leads. Excellent storytelling.  Grade: A+.

37art

The visuals on this book by Tony Shasteen can’t help but impress. The leads look great, with Sisko being reflective on Page 4 a standout moment. I was completely taken by the likeness of the individual that first appears on Page 8; this is the best I’ve even seen this character look in a comic book.

Q’s appearance is delightfully different from his earlier incarnations as he adopts a decidedly alien look, which Shasteen carries off well. Kira’s appearance is a stunner, and she’s wearing the exact opposite of what the Intendant would wear. One character comes up sadly short: McCoy. The bottom of Pages 7 and 8 have him looking anemic. What’s the deal with Shasteen’s McCoy?

This falls under a nit, but one part of this issue that is really poor is the double-paged spread of Pages 2 and 3. The center image was an incredible waste of space. This portion of the story deals with the fall of the Alpha Quadrant and this was the best Shasteen could do to visually show it? Instead, the four insert panels should have been expanded and details increased within them. I have never seen space ignored like this before.

Many of the panels use photographs and they integrate fairly seamlessly with the characters, such as Page 4, 7, 8,9, 11, etc. The third panel sticks out like a Costco’s interiors. Again, this is only one panel out of an entire book, but when all else looks so superb, this really is noticeable.  Grade: A-.

37letters

Dialogue and two sounds are crafted by Neil Uyetake. There is no need for sounds in this story, so Uyetake can’t be nicked for their absence, and his dialogue is smooth to read. Grade: A.

37covers-thumb

Bottom line:
The excellence continues in this third chapter of “The Q Gambit” as more classic characters appear, along with some formidable, classic villains. Grade: A-.

– Reviewed by Comics Editor Patrick Hayes

div_spacer

trek37-small Order Star Trek #37:
The Q Gambit, Part 3 

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Enterprise Model Curator, Smithsonian’s National Air and Space Museum

We reported back in April that as part of a large overhaul of the Smithsonian’s National Air and Space Museum, the original Constitution-class Enterprise filming model will undergo a full evaluation and restoration, and then return to the main museum hall.

[iframe src=”http://www.youtube.com/embed/KYIB17NXetU” width=”560″ height=”315″]
 
This is the first restoration for the Enterprise model in nearly twenty-five years, and to make sure we got the most insightful information about this new undertaking, we went right to the source — Dr. Margaret Weitekamp, curator of the Air and Space Museum’s spaceflight collection, who will be overseeing the Enterprise project over the next two years.

div_spacer

TREKCORE: Tell us about the new Milestones of Flight hall – how was the Enterprise model was chosen to be included in the primary museum exhibit?

marg-photoDR. MARGARET WEITEKAMP: The museum announced in April that we’ve received a very generous gift from Boeing – and as part of that gift, the Milestones of Flight Hall is going to be redone, rethought, and reopened in July 2016 as the Boeing Milestones of Flight Hall at the Air & Space Museum building on the National Mall.

When we started looking at that space and thinking about what we wanted to do with it, we decided that most of the artifacts there will remain the same. The museum has added a lot to that hall after almost forty years, but while it’s never featured ALL of the milestones, it’s been one of the places that the museum has featured the fastest, the firsts, and the things that have gone the furthest.

The main theme in the revised Boeing Milestones of Flight hall is going to be more about how aviation and spaceflight has transformed the world, from the availability of being able to travel across long distances easily but also all of the revolutions in satellite technology and what that has done of what we know about ourselves, our planet, and our universe.

photo-hall

One of the things we wanted to add to the hall was an ‘imagination’ portion – the museum had always had in its collection things that reflect popular culture interests and the ways that spaceflight has been imagined, because there’s a rich relationship between the ways people have imagined what it would be like to live and work in space, and the things that people have actually been able to do in space.

If there’s any one piece in the hall that tells the broader cultural story of imagination and inspiration, I couldn’t think of anything better than the original Enterprise studio model.

TREKCORE: It’s a lovely coincidence that the model will be added to this featured exhibit in 2016, the year of the Star Trek franchise’s fiftieth anniversary.

WEITEKAMP: Yes, it works out very nicely! As the curator for the Enterprise model, I had been looking for several years for an opportunity to give the model some refurbishment and to take a good look at its condition. The model hasn’t actively been worked on since 1991; I wanted another look at the paint, another look at the structure.

It’s in pretty good shape for being almost fifty years old, but studio models are notoriously built exactly as cheaply as possible to get the shots the film crews want. It was not built to be a museum piece, but for a specific function within the television world.

photo-hanging

It had always been designed to be on a floor-mounted stand; that’s how it was used during the television production. When the museum received it in 1974, the team at the time arranged it to hang on display, and it hung for almost twenty years until we were able to have the custom display case we built in 2000.

There’s always a challenge when you convert things that were not built for a long life into museum pieces which are meant to last for years.

TREKCORE: You mentioned the model’s paint scheme – as you’re likely aware, the paint changes made by the 1991 restoration team have been a point of fairly serious debate among fans ever since it debuted.

Will you be using the various reference material that has become available since then – like Blu-ray screencaps and restored production photography – in the new project?

WEITEKAMP: Well, we’ll certainly be going back into the museum’s own records on the model, and then also take a look at the best information we can find in order to figure out what needs to be done – and what we are able to do.

paint-quote

The museum’s approach is one of conservation, so we’re treating the model as a historic object – we don’t have carte blanche to just do anything we want with it, just like every other piece in our collection. The idea that you would want to add a modern glass canopy or something to the Spirit of St. Louis is a neat idea, but that’s now how we treat these things.

What I want to do, really, is take a look at what we need to do to make sure the model is stable and safe, and then to use the latest science that we have through our conservation lab to figure out what we can learn about the model in terms of its structural integrity and its appearance.

We’ll be doing a lot of research on its appearance as part of this project, and definitely looking at the paint as I know it’s something the fans have been very concerned about. As a fan myself, I’m obviously interested in seeing this object come back to its best possible condition – understanding that it’s still going to look like a fifty-year-old model. I’m not interested in making it all shiny!

photo-cage

photo-saucers

I would say, mainly, that we haven’t made any final decisions about any of the structural or aesthetic issues at this point; we’re just now getting into the lab and beginning to get a look at the model.

Our chief conservator is putting together a new report over the next few weeks, so hopefully we can sit down this fall and really figure out what the issues are that we have to deal – and what choices need to be made about how to move forward.

TREKCORE: Obviously, it’s still early and you need to analyze the Enterprise model fully, but do you have an idea of a timeline for the project?

WEITEKAMP: Well, it’s really going to depend on what needs to be done for the model – and in terms of it coming out back on display, that’s going to have to depend on the rest of the Milestones of Flight work.

The advantage of connecting this to the Milestones project is that it will allow us to put the model in the main space just as visitors enter the museum, but it also means that we have to coordinate the installation of the new display with the rest of the work that’s being done in that section of the building. There are a lot of moving parts to think about between now and 2016.

quote2

TREKCORE: Can you give us some more details about the conservation lab, and what kind of work the team may be facing when they start examining the model?

WEITEKAMP: The Steven F. Udvar-Hazy Center, out by Dulles Airport in Virginia, opened in 2003, and the space hanger attached opened in 2004 – and just in the last few years, we were able to open some additional behind-the-scenes facilities there as well, which has given us some additional object storage, and allowed us to move our restoration shop from a location in Maryland.

So the Enterprise model has been moved to the Emil Buehler Conservation Laboratory. This lab gives our conservation team a place where they can really use some of the latest science to take a look at the model – things like using spectroscopy to look, chemically, at what paints and exposes have been used on an aircraft or spacecraft or model, in this case – and then be able to make judgments about what kinds of treatments they want to use.

We have wonderfully talented people, and great artifacts, but this facility gives us a more state-of-the-art space in which to do some of this conservation work.

photo-shuttle

TREKCORE: It certainly makes a certain amount of sense for the Enterprise model to travel to the Udvar-Hazy Center, now that the space shuttle Enterprise is no longer parked in the McDonnell hanger!

WEITEKAMP: [laughs] It’s a name with a very rich history. We’ve always had more than one Enterprise in the Smithsonian collection – we also have a very good model of the Enterprise aircraft carrier – but it certainly makes things less confusing in our spaceflight staff meetings now that the space shuttle Discovery is here instead!

TREKCORE: Do you anticipate having to outsource any of the work that might be outside of the conservation lab’s capabilities?

WEITEKAMP: Our plan is to do everything at the Buehler lab, and I don’t anticipate taking it offsite again. Some of that, of course, will depend on what we find when we start taking a close look at the model.

quote3

We’ve been doing inspections over the years, and of course the fan community keeps us aware of the condition of the model. We’ve been seeing some aging and crazing in the paint, and I’m a little concerned with some structural issues.

The design of the Enterprise as a ship is that it looks like it can’t easily exist in Earth’s gravity; I had a very good conversation with Mike Okuda who was telling me that he’s never had a model of the Enterprise that hasn’t had some sort of similar issues due to gravity. At some point, things just start to sag.

There’s a little bit of separation in the nacelles that I’m concerned about, and we’re going to take a look and how best that can be addressed.

TREKCORE: Have you been in touch with anyone else from the Star Trek production team to assist with the project, to serve as franchise consultants?

WEITEKAMP: I have, and now that we finally have the model off display, I can now formally get in touch with people and request some of their assistance and support – so I don’t have names I can give out just yet. But yes, we’re looking at doing that.

photo-basement

TREKCORE: That sounds like a lot of good plans – and a lot of fans will surely be happy to see the model out of the basement.

WEITEKAMP: I think that this attempt to save it for public access has just gotten misconstrued over time as a sign of disrespect for this cultural icon.

Back in the 1990’s, this was an object that didn’t really have a home. It had been part of various displays, and then it was part of a traveling Star Trek exhibit – at some point, when it came back, there wasn’t a permanent display place available. At eleven feet long, it can’t easily be tucked into a corner!

Some of my predecessors were able to find a space in the gift shop – and get that custom case built in the basement level – as a way to ensure that it stayed on public display and out of an Indiana Jones-style storage facility. It would have been well preserved, of course, but it would have been out of the public view.

quote5

As the curator for this piece, my thoughts have always been that I wasn’t going to move it until I could get it – conservationally speaking – into a situation as good as it had in the gift shop. It had a custom case away from natural light and in a position where I didn’t have to worry about vibration or other things physically damaging the model.

I’ve been well aware that fans were interested in having it moved; to see it more in the context of the other artifacts that we have in the Smithsonian’s national collection. The opportunity we have now to bring it into the Milestones space really sold me on doing this new work on the model, to have a new custom case built, and to get it back in the conversation with the other artifacts in the collection.

Anytime you move something this large and this delicate, there’s always the danger of doing damage to it, so we try not to make these types of decisions lightly. If we’re going to take on a project of this scope and complexity, we want to make sure that we’ve got a clear sense of where it’s going when it’s completed, and how it’s going to be exhibited.

I’m very pleased with the opportunity to put it back into the collection in the Milestones gallery.

TREKCORE: So you don’t do it until you can do it right!

WEITEKAMP: Yes! [laughs] I’ve been working for this for about three or four years, thinking about ways to put the pieces in place to make it happen. I’m very happy with this, and I’m especially happy that the Enterprise model has made it from the National Mall in Washington, D.C., to the conservation lab in Virginia.

photo-moving

People thought I was going to be excited that it was moving, and I told them that I’d be a lot more excited once it got there safely! It’s a wonderful piece, and it’s a little nerve-wracking to stand there and watch it hang from a crane!

TREKCORE: We know how early it is in the process – and there’s a lot to figure out yet – but we’d really love to check in with you and your team over the next several months to follow the process moving forward.

WEITEKAMP: Oh, we’d be very interested in that. We’re excited to take on this project – we’re fans of the show, fans of the franchise, and obviously, fans of this model. I’m glad to be able to do this work and share it with the fans.

Museum curators believe that all of our objects are alive – they all have lives before they arrive at the museum, and they continue to have lives through their exhibit and their interaction with people who come to see them.

It’s very clear to me that the Enterprise model is an object that has a very rich life and a lot of people are very passionate about it. It definitely keeps the bar raised for making sure that we do right by it.

TREKCORE: Thanks so much for your time, Dr. Weitekamp – we look forward to speaking with you again!

Dr. Margaret A. Weitekamp curates the Air and Space Museum’s social and cultural dimensions of spaceflight collection, more than 4,000 artifacts that include space memorabilia and space science fiction objects.

These everyday mementos of the space age – which include toys and games, clothing and stamps, medals and awards, buttons and pins, as well as comics and trading cards – complete the story about spaceflight told by the Museum’s collection of space hardware and technologies.

This interview has been condensed and edited for clarity.

div_spacer

smithsonian-text

interview1interview2interview3interview3interview3interview3

REVIEW: “Star Trek: Seekers — Point of Divergence”

Star Trek: Seekers #2
Point of Divergence

By Dayton Ward & Kevin Dilmore
Release Date: August 26, 2014
Pocket Books

 

From the back cover:

The Taurus Reach. Once the conquered realm of a powerful alien species, this region remains largely shrouded in mystery even as it brims with potential for exploration and colonization. The Federation has sent in two of its finest starships on a quest to uncover the secrets it may yet hold…

The Tomol are a primitive civilization occupying a lone island on a remote world. Their culture is an enigma, centered on every member’s commitment to a painful, fiery self-sacrifice upon reaching maturity. But one of their clan has shunned this obligation, triggering a transformation into a new, powerful life form.

Answering the distress call of the USS Sagittarius—which has crashed on the planet following a fierce battle with the Klingons—Captain Atish Khatami and the crew of the Starship Endeavour must now attempt a rescue mission… even as they are locked in battle with the evolving, increasingly malevolent Tomol who, if allowed to escape their home world, pose an imminent threat to the entire galaxy!

My thoughts:

Among my favorite aspects of Star Trek: Vanguard were the dual crews of the USS Sagittarius and the USS Endeavour. The Sagittarius, a small Archer-class scout, was quite unlike any other Starfleet vessel seen on Trek before. The other, the Endeavour, was a little more familiar: a Constitution-class heavy cruiser like the Enterprise. The Endeavour takes center seat in this, the second of the Seekers novels.

There is a great deal to like about this novel. The writing team of Ward and Dilmore is back writing Trek together again for the first time since Vanguard: What Judgments Come back in 2011. Together they have crafted a solid second entry in this fledgling series, topping off an exciting story with a conclusion that is ultimately quite satisfying.

endeveour

Much like the previous novel, one area in which this book excels is with the character work. The relationships between the characters are a joy to read, particularly the interplay between Dr. Leone and nearly every other character.

Also a treat was the captain to captain relationship that developed between Captain Khatami of the Endeavour and the Klingon Captain Kang. The grudging respect that Kang initially shows towards Khatami evolves into a true recognition of her skill and honor as a ship master, and I loved Kang’s comparisons of Khatami and Kirk.

The pacing of the novel is quite good, and I found that I finished it quite quickly. It was a little slower than book one, but still a very engaging and a fun read. While the action sequences aren’t quite as nail-biting as the ones in Mack’s Second Nature, I still found the story very gripping.

I very much enjoyed the twist with regards to the nature of the Tomol and the role that both the Shedai and the Preservers played in their history. The end of the novel and the resolution to the Tomol crisis had a very Star Trek feel to it, in the best sense of the term. Throughout both books, the Changed among the Tomol have been set up as an implacable foe with no discernible reason governing their actions.

kang

However, the final resolution shows that even the most fearsome enemy can be reasoned with, and that there is no such thing as absolute evil. As I mentioned above, it is a very Star Trek ending.

Blink and you’ll miss it: keep an eye out on page 214 for a Fight Club reference. It’s not exactly subtle, but it was pretty cool to see!

Final thoughts:

As usual, a very fun, well-paced outing from the team of Dayton Ward & Kevin Dilmore. With the conclusion of this two-part story, the Sagittarius and the Endeavour are ready to head out on their dual missions of exploration in the Taurus Reach.

If this story is any indication, I am very much going to enjoy following these crews on their voyage into the unknown. More Seekers, please!

– Reviewed by Literature Editor Dan Gunther

div_spacer

Order Seekers #2:
Point of Divergence

“Compendium” Roundup: Blu-ray Easter Eggs, STID iTunes Update, and Our Giveaway Contest Winner!

bomb-wires

Since we published our review of the Star Trek: The Compendium Blu-ray set, we’ve learned of two hidden “easter egg” features buried in the new Into Darkness bonus disc — each carried over from the XBOX package. Each can be accessed through the menu screen we’ve captured below, by scrolling to the highlighted features and pressing LEFT to reveal a hidden Starfleet delta.

The first clip features Karl Urban on set, ready to disarm one of the Section 31 torpedoes, talking about an experience in an acting class early in his career; the second features Simon Pegg and Deep Roy goofing around on the San Francisco nightclub set, acting out the famous “I drink your milkshake!” scene from 2007’s There Will Be Blood.

*   *   *

stid_itunes_header

Good news for you iTunes users! If you purchased a copy of 2009’s Star Trek or Star Trek Into Darkness through the iTunes Store, or redeemed a digital code included with your Blu-ray purchases, you can now access all of the Star Trek and Into Darkness bonus features — everything included in the Compendium release — as part of the iTunes Extras package. (Not included are the above easter eggs.)

itunes-stid

Unfortunately, iTunes no longer allows the Extras bundle to download to your Mac or PC, so you’ll need to stream the content from within the iTunes Store online.

Thanks to Vincent for tip!

*   *   *

comp-banner

Finally, we’re pleased to announce that Ronald Oliver of Stockon, CA, has won our Star Trek: The Compendium Blu-ray giveway.

oliver

Congratulations, Ron!

div_spacer

Order Star Trek:
The Compendium
on Blu-ray today!


Order Star Trek Into Darkness on 3D Blu-ray today!



REVIEW: “The Klingon Art of War”

6

artofwarThe Klingon Art of War:
Ancient Principles of Ruthless Honor
Translated by Keith R.A. DeCandido
Release Date: May 6, 2014
Pocket Books

 

From the back cover:

Passed down from the time of Kahless, ten precepts have shaped Klingon culture and indoctrinated Klingons in the Way of the Warrior.

With this new translation, people from all walks of life-and all worlds-can harness the ancient Klingon wisdom and learn to embody courage, discipline, and honor.

CHOOSE YOUR ENEMIES WELL · STRIKE QUICKLY OR STRIKE NOT
ALWAYS FACE YOUR ENEMY · SEEK ADVERSITY
REVEAL YOUR TRUE SELF IN COMBAT · DESTROY WEAKNESS
LEAVE NOTHING UNTIL TOMORROW · CHOOSE DEATH OVER CHAINS
DIE STANDING UP · GUARD HONOR ABOVE ALL

My thoughts:

The Klingon Art of War (or qeS’a’ in Klingon) marks an occasion I have been waiting for for some time: the return of Keith R.A. DeCandido to the Trek literature arena… well, sort of. I mean, this book isn’t exactly a Star Trek novel, but it is a work of fiction. An in-universe reference book, if you will. But boy, is it tempting to call it non-fiction!

klingons

Using examples from throughout the history of the Klingon civilization, the book’s “author,” renowned novelist K’Ratak, dispenses sage wisdom for Klingons and non-Klingons alike — and for both warriors and non-warriors. The precepts and their implications are meant to be used by people from all walks of life, from the warrior on the deck of a Vor’cha-class attack cruiser to a well-known author dealing with his critics!

I very much enjoyed the “voice” of K’Ratak as he relays the original stories behind the precepts, as well as his own “author commentary” on each precept and the morals it conveys. I especially enjoyed the stories he told of his own life and times in which the lessons of the qeS’a’ informed his behavior. This was the perfect project for Klingon expert DeCandido. I have not yet read his I.K.S. Gorkon / Klingon Empire novels, but after reading this book, I realize that they have to be made a priority in the near future.

The references in the book to the wider Star Trek literature world are very welcome, including mention of the Typhon Pact, indicating that the book is written contemporaneous to the current post-Nemesis 24th century novel continuity. I love it when the lit-verse and canon Trek come together in these supplemental works. As much as I enjoyed Federation: The First 150 Years from a couple of years ago, I was disappointed when it didn’t completely mesh with the modern novels. The Klingon Art of War does much better in this area.

klingon2

Finally, the art work at the beginning of each chapter is very well done, and perfectly fitting for this book. The style and layout is fun to read, and I recommend The Klingon Art of War for any fan of Trek and the Klingons!

– Reviewed by Literature Editor Dan Gunther

div_spacer

Order
The Klingon Art of War:

“Star Trek: The Compendium” Blu-ray Giveaway!

TrekCore has teamed up with Paramount Home Entertainment to give away a copy of the brand-new, four-disc Star Trek: The Compendium Blu-ray set, in stores this week!

trek-compendium

We’ve got a copy of the new movie collection ready to ship out to one lucky TrekCore reader! All you need to do is reply to this post in the comment section below, and answer this question:

comp-quote

Take your pick from anyone from the three television seasons, or the six original Star Trek films, and we’ll choose one random entrant to win a free copy of the Compendium Blu-ray set!

div_spacer

Contest Rules

  • Giveaway open to residents of the United States and Canada only.
  • Contest runs through 11:59 PM Eastern on Friday, September 12, 2014.
  • Only one comment per user; users with multiple comments will be disqualified.
  • Must be a registered user of the Disqus comment system with a valid email address;
    ‘guest’ users or users with invalid email addresses are excluded from this contest.

(Some readers may not like that final requirement, but we know that many of you
don’t use Twitter or Facebook — and we need to be able to contact the winner!)

Trek Comics Review: ‘City on the Edge of Forever’ #3

Our Trek Comics editor Patrick Hayes has his review of IDW Publishing’s third City on the Edge of Forever comic adaptation, based on writer Harlan Ellison’s original teleplay.

city3-cover

She’s finally on the covers! Edith Keeler, drawn as Joan Collins, debuts in this issue, and seeing her on the cover already has my heart breaking.

Juan Ortiz provides the artwork for the regular cover. This is a great 1960’s inspired mash-up of Kirk and Edith, looking longingly into each other’s eyes against a star field, while below is the silhouette of the city. Absolutely gorgeous and tear inducing — if you know what’s coming.  Grade: A.

Don’t you dare think that Paul Shipper is going to slide on the subscription cover, because his cover looks great! Kirk, Edith, and Spock look just like the actors who played them. Kirk looks worried, Edith looks to the sky, and skeptical Spock considers his captain’s relationship with their focal point in the past. These three are above a city that looks terrific, as an automobile goes down the street. This is just as good as the regular cover.  Grade: A.

city3-story

Scott and David Tipton continue with their excellent adaptation of Harlan Ellison’s original teleplay, and this contains the entrance fans have been eagerly awaiting.

But first — having just escaped an angry mob — Kirk and Spock hide in a basement. Spock makes some very emotional commentary on humanity that has Kirk’s temper rise as well, until they both realize they’re under considerable stress. The officers find some familiar-looking clothing to blend into their new surroundings. They’re discovered by a “native” that restores the pair’s faith in humanity.

Morning finds them at work and Kirk making the decision to use a damaged piece of technology to get some answers. The commentary from this device on Page 6 reminded me of the Enterprise’s computer being delightfully out of whack. The clue it gives is super and isn’t solved for a few pages.

Spock’s job brings a new depth to what he endured in the past. It’s only hinted at in the aired episode, but in this original version of the story he’s not working with Kirk and he’s treated very differently than his captain. Who couldn’t understand his response?

The dialogue of his boss is infuriating to read, but, sadly, not surprising. Spock’s response on Page 9 is beautiful. Even more beautiful is what he finds on 10. I was so glad to see this reveal done slowly and the Vulcan’s reaction is great.

Starfleet’s most famous science officer has all the best lines in this issue and it’s impossible not to hear them in Leonard Nimoy’s voice. His closing comments on Pages 14 and 16 are chilling with their foreshadowing. It’s also impossible not to hear the music of Fred Steiner when Kirk and Edith first meet. Their banter is sweet, yet someone watches with trepidation.

This issue stepped things up with our leads finally in the past and Edith being found. I loved this.  Grade: A+.

city3-art

I was completely swept away by J.K. Woodward’s artwork this month.

To see any emotion out of Spock is always a revelation, and he’s emoting strongly: Page 1, panel four; Page 2, panels one, two, four, and five; Page 5, panel seven; and all of Pages 9 – 11. Kirk has all the humor and passion that William Shatner brought to the role, complete with that roguish smile: Page 1, panel four; Page 2, panels three and six; Page 3, panel eight; Page 7, panel six; Page 13, panel six; Page 15, panel three; and all of the four final pages.

And Edith Keeler — wow! Any reader can understand why Kirk falls for her. Her sincerity beams out of her brilliantly on Pages 11, 12, and 17 – 20. Edith’s smile would stop any man in his tracks. The supporting characters on this book, such as the gentlemen that first appear on 3 and 8, are original characters by Woodward, but they look as though they stepped out of the series.

The settings also look great. This story goes to several locations not shown in the episode, and, again, they look fantastic. Woodward moves the point of view around like an expert director, making every shot interesting with details. This may sound sacrilegious to the story, but if a page were wholly devoted to one of the characters just walking though one of the environments in silence, I’d be a happy camper.

This issue has the best visuals of the series yet. Grade: A+.

city3-letters

Dialogue and sounds are all produced by Neil Uyetake. He perfectly places each — and there’s a lot of dialogue — without stepping on the superior visuals. It takes a talented letterer to do this, and Uyetake has got plenty of talent.  Grade: A+.

city-covers-thumb

Bottom line:
City on the Edge of Forever #3 is the best chapter yet, and is an absolute must-read. It definitely earns my highest possible recommendation.  Grade: A+.

– Reviewed by Comics Editor Patrick Hayes

div_spacer

city3-small Order Harlan Ellison’s
City on the Edge of Forever #3

REVIEW: “These Are The Voyages: TOS Season Two”

TATV-2These Are The Voyages: TOS Season Two
Marc Cushman with Susan Osborn
Release Date: March 2, 2014
Jacobs Brown Press

From the back cover:

In the 1980’s, Gene Roddenberry and Robert H. Justman gave Marc Cushman permission to write the definitive history of the first Star Trek. They backed their stamp of approval by providing documentation never before shared with the public. These Are The Voyages, published in three volumes – one designated for each season of the Original Series) – will take you back in time and put you into the producers’ offices, the writers’ room, onto the soundstages, and in front of your TV sets for the first historic broadcasts. Included are hundreds of memos between Roddenberry and his staff, production schedules, budgets, fan letters, behind-the-scenes images, and the TV ratings. Buckle your seat belts; the trek of a lifetime continues with Season Two.

My thoughts:

As with the first These Are The Voyages, Marc Cushman has provided fans with a gargantuan, meticulously-researched volume of facts, trivia, and first-hand accounts of the creation of Star Trek, this time chronicling the classic television show’s second season. The opening chapters focus on the transition from season one to season two, including the suspense with regards to whether or not the expensive-to-produce show would be renewed. The story of Star Trek behind the scenes is just as exciting as the Star Trek we got on our television sets each week. The very real sense of franticness and difficulty in producing Star Trek is palpable as one reads the pages of this section. tos-s2a Individual episodes are featured in production order as the discussion between the producers, writers, and the network is chronicled, with each episode getting a separate chapter. The cast of characters featured by Cushman are at times both larger-than-life and surprisingly human. Through their memos regarding each episode’s script and production, we hear the voices of each of the producers and writers: Gene Roddenberry often insisting on a larger “message” to include in each script, Gene Coon focused on creating and maintaining a consistent “Star Trek feel,” Dorothy Fontana and her brilliant eye for characters and drama, and Robert Justman’s protestations about budget and believably couched in a sometimes dark sense of humor. Also included in each episode’s summary are reminiscences of guest actors and writers, the Neilsen ratings, and the historical context in which each episode was produced. Reportedly, Cushman’s editor did a lot of work to get him to trim back the amount of information included in this book. I can see how it would have been easy to get carried away. Even with the trims, there is a lot here, more than in the first book. And I’m informed that the third volume has even more with which to fill its pages! Interstitial chapters feature various writers and other background personnel as they join the production, such as David Gerrold and John Meredyth Lucas. Other sections are included, such as depictions of Star Trek in the popular media of the time and, of particular interest, an overview of story ideas that were purchased and in some cases even developed, but never aired. tos-s2b As with the first volume, the real joy in These Are The Voyages: TOS Season Two comes in sitting down with the hefty tome and rewatching the episodes. Even someone such as myself, who has seen each episode an uncountable number of times, can pick new things out of the show while following along with Cushman as he revisits the world of 1960’s television production.

Final thoughts:

Above all else, this book is a lot of fun to read. Even the most ardent Star Trek fan will find something new and exciting about their favorite entertainment in the pages of These Are The Voyages. And, as mentioned above, Season 3 has even more to talk about. I am very fascinated to learn more about that troubled season, and I am very much looking forward to the third and final volume of These Are The Voyages.

– Reviewed by TrekCore’s Literature Editor, Dan Gunther

div_spacer

Order These Are The Voyages: TOS S2

German “Chain of Command” Blu-ray now available

Just like “The Best of Both Worlds,” “Redemption,” and “Unification,” German audiences can now pick up a copy of “Chain of Command” on Blu-ray — with German-language packaging — through select local supermarkets priced at €9.99. The single-disc set includes the same foldout slipcover included with the North American release.

German-COCImage from the CineFacts.de forum

We’re pleased that German fans have the opportunity to pick up a copy of “Geheime Mission auf Celtris Drei” (or, “The Secret Mission to Celtris III”) in their home territory, but for those German speakers who don’t have access to a local store, we recommend purchasing the disc from Amazon.com.

div_spacer

Have any of you been able to track down a copy of this release in a market near you? Let us know in the comments below!

Order Star Trek:
TNG - Season 6
on Blu-ray
today!



Order TNG's
"Chain of Command"
on Blu-Ray
today!