Home Blog Page 201

Book Report: STAR TREK Novels Take a Break in 2018

November saw the release of David Mack’s Star Trek: Titan — Fortune of War, but as we covered in our recent Trek publishing calendar guide, there have only been three Simon & Schuster Trek novels announced for 2018, an unusual gap after decades of regular, monthly releases from their Pocket Books line.

Star Trek: Discovery novels Drastic Measures and the just-announced Fear Itself are due in February and June — along with the rescheduled release of Kirsten Beyer’s Star Trek: Voyager — Architects of Infinity — but past that, the only print Trek storytelling known at present will be coming from IDW Publishing’s ongoing comic line, and the second two English-translation Star Trek: Prometheus novels, due in May and November from Titan Books, a separate publisher.

In addition, as far as we can tell, none of the regular authors that have been a part of the Star Trek publishing line in recent years including David Mack, Dayton Ward, Christopher L. Bennett, and Greg Cox are currently under contract for additional Trek books.

“I’ve fulfilled the requirements of my current contract,” Mack wrote in a post on the TrekBBS in back in March, “but it’s my hope to return to Star Trek (and other licensed universes) at some point in the future, simply because I enjoy doing so.”

In another thread speculating on the lack of book release announcements for 2018, Ward said in November that while he has a list of unannounced projects on his blog that include Star Trek projects, “None of the ‘unannounced tie-ins’ on that list are for Pocket.”

Ward’s February ‘Discovery’ title “Drastic Measures” wraps up his current ‘Trek’ slate.

It’s extremely unusual for Simon & Schuster’s Star Trek novel line that there are only three novels on the schedule, and has sparked concerns among fans. The company has held the license to publish Star Trek novels since 1979, and from at least 1995 — with few exceptions — has published at least one new Star Trek novel every month, with new titles announced months in advance of their release.

It appears the answer to this issue lies in renegotiation of the current license between CBS and Simon & Schuster, which expired this year. For months, Trek authors with an active presence online and in the fandom have indicated that the two companies are in the middle of renegotiating their agreements.

Simon & Schuster editor Ed Schesinger spoke briefly about the situation when we attended the publisher’s panel at the 2017 Star Trek convention in Las Vegas back in August — stating that despite this current situation, the Star Trek novel line would certainly be continuing.

As part of that renegotiation, Schlesinger revealed that Simon & Schuster had successfully expanded the license to include elements of the Kelvin Timeline film series, likely requiring additional conversations with Paramount Pictures and JJ Abrams’ production company Bad Robot which may have complicated the process.

Spock tries to outrun the Hobus supernova before being thrown into the Kelvin Timeline in ‘Star Trek’ (2009).

Why is that a big deal? As Christopher L. Bennett detailed in August:

“It will let authors] finally [be] to show the destruction of Romulus and its Prime Universe aftermath, or being able to refer to/depict the [USS] Kelvin and [Captain] Robau in the 23rd century or the Franklin and Edison in the 22nd….

A number of CBS licensees, like IDW Comics and the Star Trek Online computer game, were able to use Kelvin content, and there were several YA Kelvinverse novels from Simon Spotlight. After all, CBS owns all of Star Trek. Paramount Pictures licenses the movie rights from CBS, as a legacy of their origins as a single company…. so all Trek tie-ins and merchandise, even Kelvin tie-ins and merchandise, have to be approved by CBS.

It’s just that Kelvin material also needs Paramount’s and Bad Robot’s approval, which makes it a little more complicated to license. For whatever reason, Pocket Books didn’t manage to get that license [originally] even though other licensees did.

In addition, Dayton Ward in mentioned that there has also been a change in leadership at Gallery Books, the division of Simon & Schuster that publishes the Star Trek novel line, which may have delayed the license negotiations.

“At last report, the deal was being finalized,” Ward wrote in the post dated November 6. “There was a change in leadership at S&S/Gallery Books a short while back… that likely interrupted whatever discussions were in process, for Trek as well as any number of other things.”

“All we know,” wrote Christopher L. Bennett last week, “is that the [contract] renewal was delayed because the new person wanted to review the agreement and have input, but that seems pretty routine and doesn’t necessarily mean anything will be changed. It doesn’t rule out some sort of change, but it’s impossible to guess what it might be. Eventually, hopefully soon, we’ll actually find out.”

(We reached out to Simon & Schuster regarding this story; the publisher declined to comment.)

Regardless of what happens, Star Trek fans will need to brace themselves for a break in the novel line, even if contracts were signed today, given the lead time necessary for new novels to go from contract to print. The wait may even rival or exceed the previous longest break in the Star Trek novel line in recent years, when several planned Kelvin Timeline tie-in novels were unexpectedly canceled and we were without new novels for four months in 2010.

The announced-then-cancelled Kelvin Timeline novels, once planned for a 2010 release.

But could we see at least one of those novels — which included works by Alan Dean Foster, Christopher L. Bennett, David Mack, and Greg Cox — as a result of this gap in the schedule? While story points from Cox’s The Hazard of Concealing and Bennett’s Seek a Newer World were recycled for use in post-2010 prime-universe books (like Cox’s No Time Like the Past and Bennett’s The Face of the Unknown), Mack said in a recent podcast interview that there are possibilities his book might yet see the light of day.

“I’ve heard rumors that if and when the Star Trek guys get their book line going again…  my book, which is titled More Beautiful Than Death, might actually get resurrected,” Mack revealed, but cautioned that it is still in the rumor stage right now. “That’s not confirmed. I’ve not seen it on a schedule, nobody has confirmed it to me. I’ve only heard the rumors. I’ve heard that they’re talking about it.”

As a big fan of the Star Trek novels who has been blessed with new books every month for as long as I can remember, it’s disappointing to be in a position where there are few new novels on the horizon, and we very much share fans’ concerns and dismay. If the end result, however, allows for the incorporation of the Kelvin Timeline — which not only could bring back one of the ‘lost’ novels, but also may allow the 24th Century storytelling to continue past the Hobus supernova event — it may just be worth it.

“Pocket has my number,” Dayton Ward wrote confidently last month. “They know where to find me when they’re ready.”

My reviews of Star Trek: Titan — Fortune of War and Star Trek: Prometheus — Fire With Fire will be along soon, so keep checking back to TrekCore for those and all the latest news from the world of Star Trek publishing!

DISCOVERY’s Next Novel is “Fear Itself,” Coming June 5

Star Trek: Discovery‘s ongoing tie-in novel series, which began in September with Desperate Hours and continues in February’s Drastic Measures, has been extended to a third entry — author James Swallow will bring fans the Saru-centric Fear Itself, headed for bookstores in June.

There’s no cover art or preorder links yet available — we’ll certainly update you when they arrive — but the official synopsis was revealed today, thanks to StarTrek.com.

Lieutenant Saru is a Kelpien, a member of a prey species born on a world overrun by monstrous predators…and a being who very intimately understands the nature of fear.

Challenged on all sides, he is determined to surpass his origins and succeed as a Starfleet officer aboard the U.S.S. Shenzhou. But when Saru breaks protocol in order to prove himself to his crewmates, what begins as a vital rescue mission to save a vessel in distress soon escalates out of control. Forced into a command role he may not be ready for, Saru is caught between his duty and the conflicting agendas of two antagonistic alien races.

To survive, he will need to seek a path of peace against all odds, and risk compromising the very ideals he has sworn to uphold….

On his blog, Swallow revealed that the book will be set chronologically between the first to Discovery novels:

“Fear Itself” follows on from “Desperate Hours” and “Drastic Measures” by m’colleagues David Mack and Dayton Ward and continues the theme of the Discovery novels by unfolding some more of the backstory of the show’s main characters – in my case, I’ve written a story that centres around the Kelpien science officer Saru.

The story is set after the events of Dayton’s book but before Dave’s (and also the events of the show itself), while Saru is a lieutenant serving with Michael Burnham under Captain Phillippa Georgiou aboard the U.S.S. Shenzhou.

Watch for our review of Dayton Ward’s Drastic Measures this Spring, and for more updates on the Star Trek publishing world here at TrekCore!

Novel #4:
"The Way to the Stars"


Novel #5:
"The Enterprise War"


Novel #6:
"Dead Endless"


INTERVIEW: “Star Trek: Discovery” Composer Jeff Russo

We last talked with Star Trek: Discovery series composer Jeff Russo at the September premiere out in Los Angeles, a time when the only part of his Trek score we had heard was the show’s main title theme.

Since then, Russo’s work has accompanied all nine episodes of “Chapter 1” of Discovery, and on December 15 the first soundtrack release from the newest Trek series arrives from label Lakeshore Records on digital download, followed by a debut on CD and vinyl album in early 2018.

We had a chance to spend some time with the composer to discuss both the impending soundtrack as well as his approach to scoring Star Trek: Discovery episodes from the early days of production through his current work finishing up the first season’s themes.

*   *   *

TREKCORE: At the premiere, you told us how you had enjoyed the score from the previous Trek shows and films, but you hadn’t really dug into them on a compositional level until you joined DiscoveryCould you talk a little bit about the research that you did into Trek’s musical history, and how that has influenced your work on Discovery, if at all?

JEFF RUSSO: Well, I would say that the only true influence that I inserted into the Discovery score was the classic Alexander Courage fanfare from the opening title theme — but I think that the idea of what Trek sounds like is pretty apparent in all the scores, in terms of the instrumentation and how we go about doing it.

It’s so funny — we have a joke when we’re recording the scores for Discovery; I sometimes will record the strings and the woodwinds together, and then in a separate session record the brass. And I always sort of joke around that it doesn’t really become a Star Trek score until after the brass session — because once you add that brass to some of these big cues, all of a sudden you’re like, “Yeah, there it is, there’s the Trek sound.”

So while there’s a certain sound to the type of orchestration that I do to make it feel like it’s in the Trek world, I haven’t really inserted anything musically from any of the prior projects — though I did go back and study the scores for the Mudd episodes from the Original Series when I was thinking about what to do for Episode 7 [“Madness to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad”].

In the end, though, none of what had been written or recorded for that original character was going to work in our context, because the Mudd character is being portrayed in such different a different way; it just didn’t really make much sense.

It was a lot of fun to go back to those Original Series scores and listen to the music. It’s interesting to hear just how over-the-top some of that score is, with a bit of camp sprinkled into the music, and how they played with that emotional content.

TREKCORE: Yes, it wasn’t always very subtle!

RUSSO: I think that I’m a lot more subtle when I go about trying to tell the story! [Laughs]

TREKCORE: While we’re talking story, we’re spending a lot of time in this iteration of Trek focused on the alien races — obviously the Klingons are a big factor in Discovery, we’ve spent time with Burnham and Sarek on Vulcan, and Episode 8 centered around Saru, a Kelpian, and the Pahvans.

Have you tried to take any influence from these alien cultures when writing the score for the those scenes, or do you try to stick more towards the story side of things to guide the music?

RUSSO: You know, I really try to do a little of both. I tend to want to tell stories, musically, from a character perspective. I’ve fashioned a couple of Klingon themes, themes for Burnham and her relationship with Georgiou — both in ‘reality’ and for in her memories.

There’s some also some bridge crew thematic material, and there’s definitely a Lorca theme, but overall, I would say all the different characters have a bit of their own theme, which mostly comes through in little motifs.

That mostly comes out a lot in Episode 8 [“Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum”], and that’s probably the most where I’ve done stuff that was more about Saru and the Pahvans, their story, and how that all came together.

But I think, mainly, I try to tell the story from a character perspective so I end up with themes for different characters and different relationships between those characters.

(Photo: CBS Television Studios)

TREKCORE: You’ve shared some photos of your scoring sessions on Twitter and obviously that’s done in post-production — but at what point in the process do you come in for scoring? Is it once the picture is locked from editing, or earlier while the episode is still being put together?

RUSSO: For scoring the individual episodes, yes, it’s after we have a picture lock. They send it to me and I spot the episodes with [executive producer] Alex Kurtzman. That’s when I actually start to look at it and score each episode — but in terms of thematic material, I tried to write that before the season begins.

With a show like Discovery, there’s just so much going on throughout the 15 episodes that it would have been impossible for me to come up with all of that thematic material before starting.

I had read four or five scripts before I started really getting into scoring, and I had read the first two [“The Vulcan Hello,” “Battle at the Binary Stars”] before I had taken a crack at the main title theme. Then I also started a Klingon theme, and started writing a theme for Burnham and Georgiou early on.

But mainly, it’s about two months after they shoot the episode that I will get that episode to start working on.

TREKCORE: We know each episode had an extensive post-production timeline for visual effects, but it’s interesting that you come in so far after the shooting period.

RUSSO: Yeah, except for the very beginning of production when I started writing material shortly after things got started — but not for specific episodes, just for that thematic material..

TREKCORE: During the editing process, is temp score being used to set the picture — and if so, is that a help or a challenge when it becomes your turn to start scoring?

RUSSO: Sometimes it’s a help — but sometimes it’s a challenge! [Laughs]

Temp score is used, yes, and that helps the production team make their edit, but they have been starting to use the material I’ve written for Discovery more and more, as there is more of that to pull from.But for the first three episodes or so, there wasn’t any of my score written yet.

A lot of times, I’ll just ignore the temp score and just try to do our own thing, though sometimes I’ll be told, “This temp score actually works emotionally, and does work in terms of how it’s working to picture – you may want to look at that as a reference.”

I tend to not like to do that, but occasionally, it does help.

(Photo: CBS Television Studios)

TREKCORE: Some of your scoring photos have revealed track titles like “Delicious as Always” or “Dishonor Yourselves,” and of course the new soundtrack has 20 more titles released as well. Do you have a process for choosing track titles?

RUSSO: It all depends, really. It depends on the cue, on the episode, on what’s going on at the time… sometimes I’ll be funny, or sometimes I just let my music editor pick the name.

There’s just so much music that it would be difficult for me to think about the title for every piece of music. Sometimes a title is important, though, if it has do with a line of dialogue that’s right at the beginning when the score begins, or about the scene itself.

But sometimes, it’s just about what I was thinking at the time, and nothing to do with the scene! [Laughs]

TREKCORE: Speaking of having “so much music,” this first soundtrack release is for “Chapter 1” of the season. Are all 9 episodes represented?

RUSSO: It’s a smattering of music from across all nine episodes, though I may have left one out, I can’t remember for sure. But really what I tried to do was give as much of a cross-section of the general feel of the score for the series to date, rather than try to fit everything in.

I come from a background of making albums that you can listen to straight through. Once you start packing 35 tracks onto long two-hour CD sets, nobody ever listens to everything.

And I’m sure there are going to be people who will say, “Well, where’s that ONE piece of music from that scene?” and really, it’s just impossible to put everything in. You can’t ever make everyone happy. [Laughs] But you try your best! Stuff that people are missing, like, at some point, will probably end up on my website or something.

I’m sure that everybody will be happy with what’s on there — I hope, anyway — and we will pick up with the vinyl release next year, where I’ll take some of the tracks from Chapter 1 off and replace them with score from Episodes 10 through 15.

TREKCORE: Oh, so the vinyl will be released after the season finale?

RUSSO: Yes, that’s correct. And then there’ll probably be digital-only “Chapter 2” release, which would just be music from Episodes 10 through 15.

TREKCORE: Regarding the vinyl release, it’s becoming somewhat of a trend in recent years to see movie and television scores coming to these special LP releases. What are your thoughts on these, at a time when many people go right to digital downloads for their music?

RUSSO: I think that it’s a collector’s item, you know? There are some people who enjoy listening to music on records — I know I’m one of them — and I think it’s always fun to have records to see the artwork that’s involved.

You get to see the credits and who’s done what to produce the album, you get special pictures, liner notes, and all that — it’s more about the whole item than just delivering the music, which these days is something that’s easier to do than ever.

That may be a much smaller percentage of buyers, but I still think, especially fans of a franchise like Star Trek, would be interested in something like that.

TREKCORE: There have been a few vinyl releases from the Trek feature films in the last few years, and for those who are really into the music side of fandom have definitely been excited about those sets.

RUSSO: I think that people enjoy the feeling of owning an album and all that goes with it, and I think that’s the real appeal of that.

(Photo: CBS Television Studios)

TREKCORE: From our perspective, one of the more unique episodic score moments was the music from the Burnham/Tilly jogging sequence in “Lethe,” that MIDI-esque take on the Discovery theme….

RUSSO: And that IS on the soundtrack! It’s titled “Persistence.”

TREKCORE: Oh, wonderful! It was certainly one of our favorite pieces of music from the season so far, but what about you — what’s been your favorite musical moment from the season?

RUSSO: You know, it’s a moving target. My first response was about to be “Oh, you haven’t heard it yet!”

Like, as I live with things, the new things that I’m creating for these episodes that haven’t aired yet become more fun and shiny, you know? [Laughs] So, like, there’s something at the end of Episode 10 [“Despite Yourself”] that I’m really super happy about, but I’m really happy about the end of Episode 9 [“Into the Forest I Go”] too!

I have no specific favorite part — there are a number of things that I’m really excited and happy to do, like the waltz between Stamets and Burnham in Episode 7. That was fun to do, and I really enjoyed that.

I had to write an opera and you haven’t heard that yet.

TREKCORE: Would that be Kasseelian opera, the favorite of Stamets and Culber?

RUSSO: The Kasseelian opera, that’s correct! And my saying that doesn’t reveal any story point whatsoever, other than there’s an alien race called the Kasseelians and one of them is an opera singer!

But that was really super fun to do and super amazing. I’ve just been so artistically thrilled to be able to do all of this different stuff with this show, and it’s hard for me to nail down just one favorite.

I’m partial to the main title, a I reference it a good deal in the episodic score, because it has emotional value to me. It has nostalgic value to me, meaning I can immediately bring someone back to the feeling of the show by just nodding a little bit to the theme.

I enjoy doing that because it makes it feel like it’s a whole picture.

TREKCORE: And you’re still working to score the last episodes of the season, right?

RUSSO: Yeah, I’m going to record Episode 13 on Friday, then Episodes 14 and 15 will be recorded and finished after the first of the year.

TREKCORE: And then on to Season 2!

RUSSO: Apparently so — I’ve been told that the story for Season 2 is being broken now, and at some point next year, I’ll be writing some more music!

To preorder Star Trek: Discovery – Season 1, Chapter 1 for digital download, head over to Amazon now, and you’ll get Jeff Russo’s music once the soundtrack lands on December 15.

Check back to TrekCore for our review of this soundtrack later this month!

S1 Soundtrack: Chapter 1

S1 Soundtrack: Chapter 2

S2 Soundtrack

STAR TREK 4: Tarantino Requires ‘R’ Rating, Paramount Says ‘Okay’ As Writing Prep Continues

The surprising news that writer-director Quentin Tarantino was working to pitch a Star Trek sequel film story broke on Monday evening, and today there’s more detail known about the status of this still-stunning development out of Hollywood.

Following up on his scoop from earlier this week, Deadline‘s Mike Fleming, Jr. reports today that not only is the Trek 4 development kicking along quickly, but that Tarantino has already “met for hours in a writers room” with writers Drew Pearce (Iron Man 3Mission: Impossible – Rogue Nation), Lindsey Beer, and apparent “frontrunner” Mark L. Smith (The Revenant).

In addition, the biggest jaw-dropper of this story is that Tarantino has “required” that his Trek take be an R-rated endeavor, and both producer J.J. Abrams and studio Paramount Pictures have signed on with that rating.

From the Deadline report:

The film will most certainly go where no Star Trek has gone before: Tarantino has required it to be R rated, and Paramount and Abrams agreed to that condition.

Most mega budget tent poles restrict the film to a PG-13 rating in an effort to maximize the audience… the exception to this rule was Fox’s Deadpool, but that film started out with modest ambitions before it caught on and became the biggest R rated film ever.

That rating was crucially important to Tarantino, who hopes to direct this Star Trek and who has helmed R rated films his entire career.

Tarantino certainly is no stranger to violence and other R-rated elements from his past films like Resevoir DogsPulp FictionInglorious BasterdsThe Hateful Eight, and Kill Bill — but what of that adults-only tone would he bring to a Star Trek film?

We’ll have to wait and see if his story moves past the scripting stage to find out.

Trek Comics Review: TNG – MIRROR BROKEN #5

Finally, we come to the end of this amazing thrill ride, and I have to be honest about the Star Trek: TNG — Mirror Broken story: I DON’T WANT IT TO BE OVER!

Scott and David Tipton with artist extraordinaire, J.K. Woodward have managed to create something truly memorable with this series, which wraps up this week with Mirror Broken #5.

My only complaint? It’s over too damn quickly. Five issues may seem like a decent length for a story arc, but when you have something this good, it’s only natural to want more.

Just to briefly recap the events from when we last left Picard and his band of freebooters, they were being chased down by Imperial Starships to return the stolen ISS Enterprise. However, before any serious battle could ensue, they were surrounded by an overwhelming number of Cardassian and Klingon warships, making this a heck of a standoff. What’s Picard’s solution? He runs.

But, given that this isn’t the familiar Next Generation universe, we can’t expect a deft ruse or diplomatic solution, right? So, in true buccaneer fashion, Picard turns, stands, and fights… and the battle is monumentally epic!

I don’t want to give anything away – it’s an innovative and creative battle that makes use of this Enterprise’s special nature and needs to be enjoyed without any fear of spoilers. But this is a saga that sees the making of the stuff of legends. In this case, it’s a five-issue origin story that sees the crew of the Enterprise in this universe coming together. In all honesty, I find I actually preferred this adventure to “Encounter at Farpoint.”

Woodward’s art is spectacularly accurate to the finest degree. Not only are his likenesses brilliant, but he manages to fit in little details that might get unnoticed if you aren’t looking carefully. For example, in the mess hall party, watch to see who Riker is trying to impress, with a jealous Inquisitor Troi watching over his shoulder.

Also, when Picard stands up from his chair, just because his tunic is armless, it doesn’t stop him from executing the familiar tunic adjustment fans have come to know as “the Picard Maneuver.” It’s these details that drive home the realism of his imagery.

This iteration of the Mirror Universe makes this tale unexplored territory. The Tiptons and Woodward have created new pathways for these characters to follow and have ultimately made this trailblazing stuff to read. It’s more than just a new spin on old characters – these are new characters in terms of behaviour, dialogue and values.

There are also new potential storylines to explore in this arc as well. For example: what is the nature of the relationship between Guinan and Picard in the Mirror Universe? What about the next adventure, and, in thinking about the crew, to echo Mr. Barclay: how long can this last?

You can expect this to last a little bit more. In all candour, I can give you a full prediction right here and now, that this is NOT the end of this series. There’s too much fun for Woodward and the Tiptons to miss out on continuing the Mirror Universe adventures of the ISS Enterprise-D. So, I’m calling this one: expect another series of adventures from these creators.

  • The regular cover by Woodward is the best one by far. Not only does it show a unified crew ready to tackle anything that threatens the Empire, but it also reinforces that sense that there are more stories to come. Boldly looking towards the future is what we’ve come to expect from the regular universe Enterprise crew – why should their Mirror Universe counterparts be any different?
     
  • The subscription cover is another one of George Caltsoudas’s stylized representations. In this instance, we see Data striking an intimidating pose, complete with Borg attachments. I don’t know if it fits this particular issue. In fact, it probably would have been a better choice as a variant back-up to the Loot Crate edition that featured Data’s origin story in this universe.
     
  • The retailer-incentive cover by Rachael Stott is certainly a dramatic one, with a dominant-looking Captain Picard breaking a window with his fist as the crew looks on from behind him. As this is a story about the crew’s “baptism of fire,” so to speak; this is a better choice of covers that shows a united crew, eager to crush the enemies of the Empire.

Overall, this is a story that’s too good to miss. Mirror Broken #5 ends with the same character this tale started with: Reginald Barclay, who expresses his curiosity about the crew’s future.

As for me, I take comfort in my shared opinion with Barclay that this isn’t the last we’ve seen of the ISS Enterprise-D, and I look forward to new stories set in this universe sometime in the future.

FanSets’ DISCOVERY Episode Pins Available Individually

Previously available only as a full-series commitment, FanSets’ unique Star Trek: Discovery “Episode Pins” can now be obtained as individual purchases, for fans who only may want a handful of the ongoing releases.

Each individual pin is up for sale for $15 each (with the larger “Vulcan Hello” pin at $20), which is certainly a relief to those of you who were concerned about the subscription price point.

If you still want to nab the entire collection – including those not yet revealed for the second half of Discovery‘s first season – you can still sign up for a subscription for $225, though the “Season Pass” Starfleet Command pin will no longer be included.

*   *   *

If you haven’t entered yet, there’s still one more day to win a framed Star Trek: The Next Generation pin set — and stay tuned for another exciting giveaway from our friends at FanSets in the coming weeks, celebrating another upcoming Star Trek anniversary!

REVIEW: Eaglemoss XL — USS Enterprise NCC-1701-D

Last week we took a look at Eaglemoss’ large-size XL USS Enterprise-E, and now we’re jumping back a few years in the Trek timeline to the Galaxy-class Enterprise-D from Star Trek: The Next Generation!

Measuring just over 8.5″ in length, this XL Enterprise-D is the third rendition of TNG’s hero ship, after their 2013 debut issue featuring the Galaxy-class ship in a smaller scale (and their “All Good Things” three-nacelled variant) as a subscriber exclusive — though with a revised paint scheme to bring the ship closer to its expected hue.

LEFT: The 2013 5.5″ Enterprise-D subscriber model. (Photo courtesy of Alex Perry)

Rather than the khaki tan color on the first-run Enterprise-D, the XL edition of the ship is toned in a pale blueish-green paint which is much closer to the original filming models’ look, though featuring a great deal of hull aztec markings which are pushing a bit too heavy in this reviewer’s opinion.

The aztec design is nice in its detail and application, but toning it down by about 40% in contrast would make it a much more subtle effect which help smooth out the presentation, and also give the other hull markings a chance to stand out against the paint.

On the upper half of the saucer, the black and white window markings are all painted on, while the tan lifeboat hatches and yellow transporter emitters are painted on raised details; all which align nicely on our model.

The entire bottom of the saucer and outer area of the top are die-cast metal, while the area inside the oval-shaped phaser strip on top, including the bridge module, is a molded-plastic insert which is secured in the metal saucer with resin.

The seam between the two is visible, but the alignment with the dark-grey phaser strip helps blend it to a relatively unnoticeable join.

The underside of the saucer, all metal as mentioned, is again full of lifeboat hatches and painted-on windows – but here is where the first window alignment issues that we’ve covered before appear on this model.

Of the fourteen recessed window bays on the lower saucer, not one has the painted black window markings inside the grooved etchings in the metal. Again, if the manufacturing processes aren’t available to get the paint into the slots as marked, why are the sculpts still including these window indentations?

Moving down to the secondary hull, the neck of the Enterprise-D (and everything below it) is entirely molded plastic, with more noticeable joins for assembly. The neck area has a really odd window situation, as once again, the window paint doesn’t align with the indentations — but here the markings are all over the place, even overlapping a bit with the torpedo launcher groove.

(The XL Enterprise-E model also has these faint window grooves on its neck, but they were left unpainted — a wise decision, frankly, compared to this implementation.)

There is also a lack of Enterprise labeling on the side of the neck, and no sign of the yellow RCS thruster on the outside of the deflector; these yellow thrusters are also missing from the edges of the saucer section. While we can forgive the tiny ship name for going absent due the tiny font and unusual placement, the absence of the yellow thrusters is a bit of a glaring omission from the ship.

The deflector itself is copper ringed in bright blue plastic, but missing the detail of a second ring of blue in the inner dish as pictured above.

Moving around to the rear of the Galaxy-class model, the ship is a mostly-faithful recreation of the on-screen Enterprise-D, with appropriate hull markings and nacelle component coloring.

The bussard collectors at the front of each nacelle are a brilliant ruby red, backed by the yellow intake grilles and bright blue warp field emitters. The Starfleet pennants on each are crisp and clear, and red and green running lights are marked appropriately.

And now for the disappointing area of this section of the model: the shuttle bay and impulse engine area of the upper neck section. Several inaccuracies from the smaller edition of the Enterprise-D have carried over to the XL edition of the ship, ones that really could have been addressed in this larger-scale ship.

First, the coloring of the “1701-D” main shuttlebay markings are a bright orange-red, when the Enterprise in TNG featured yellow entry detailing. This might be a visibility thing — that the yellow may not have been legible on the hull — but it just bugs a little.

In addition, the red paint on the two saucer-section impulse engines feels very unfinished, with parts of the engine extrusions left unpainted around the edges. Just a quick moment with a hand paintbrush would have cleared that up, or replacing these with red plastic inserts would have made a nice improvement.

The real frustration in this part of the ship, though, is the middle part of the neck, home to Shuttlebays 2 and 3, and the stardrive’s impulse engine. Rather than the traditional (and screen-accurate) small and large bay doors, each of the secondary shuttlebay hatches are equal in size and placement, a carryover from the 2013 small Galaxy-class model.

Virtually every other Enterprise-D model we’ve seen have sized these hatches to match the filming model — dating back to the early Cheerios cereal model toy in 1987 — and it’s not clear why that this wasn’t addressed when scaling up the design to the XL size.

The primary impulse engine is also a bit of a rough patch, where the barely-visible red plastic insert joins with the rest of the hull — true, our photo above is a macro shot enlarging the area significantly, but it’s not that hard to see in person, either.

Finally, the red stripe down the back of the neck really should be two parallel lines; a minor nitpick, admittedly, but that’s part of the ship’s design.

We know that no model from any manufacturer is going to be perfect; there are always certain details not carried over or altered due to production requirements.

Screen-accuracy isn’t always possible — and while we admit that some of the criticisms we note above are perhaps a little too nitpicky, certain details like the shuttlebay sizes and missing yellow thrusters are hallmark details of the Galaxy-class, and it’s unfortunate that they’re not in place on the XL Enterprise-D.

That being said, if you’re able to accept the minor issues we’ve covered here — and really, they are relatively minor issues — this Enterprise-D model is a solid, well-balanced ship that is held well on its included display, and looks pretty great on the shelf among the Eaglemoss fleet – just stand back a little bit.

The XL USS Enterprise-D retails from Eaglemoss at $74.95 in the USA (and £49.99 in the UK shop) when buying individually, but drops to $59.95 if you subscribe to the Star Trek Starships XL program for ongoing delivery.

We’ll be back with reviews of the XL Enterprise NX-01 soon, along with more coverage of the Official Starships Collection throughout the month of December.

What are your thoughts on the Enterprise-D? Sound off in the comments below!

In Eaglemoss’ US store, TrekCore readers can use promo code TREKCORE at checkout for 10% off any ‘Star Trek’ collectible purchase $50 or greater (Starships, Plaques, Binders, Graphic Novels).

Win a Copy of “The Art of Star Trek: The Kelvin Timeline”

The galaxy’s newest Star Trek reference book — The Art of Star Trek: The Kelvin Timeline — is in stores today, and while we’ll bring you our review of this new book later in December, we’ve teamed up with publisher Titan Books to get a copy of this new hardcover into the hands of one lucky TrekCore reader!

This contest has ended. Congrats to winner Brett L.!

Check out our summer preview of this book from back in August, then enter to win your own copy by simply answering the question below in our comments:

From the Narada to Yorktown Station, and from Officer 0718 to Krall and Jaylah, the Kelvin Timeline Star Trek films have been full of visual wonders from digital landscapes and space sequences down to the incredible makeup effects of Joel Harlow from last year’s Star Trek Beyond.

Tell us your favorite starship, best-loved alien design, visual effects sequence, or anything else you love about the look of the Kelvin Timeline films!

Good news for our international readers, as this contest is open to residents in the United States, Canada, and the UK — so sound off in the comments below, and watch your email for the winner notification on December 11!

Add TrekCore.com to your ‘safe senders’ list so we don’t go to your spam folder!

div_spacer

Contest Rules

  • Giveaway open to residents of the USA, Canada, and the United Kingdom only.
  • Contest runs through 11:59 PM Eastern on Sunday, December 10.
  • Only one comment per user; users with multiple comments will be disqualified.
  • Must be a registered user of the Disqus comment system with a valid email address.

First STAR: TREK DISCOVERY Soundtrack Due This Month

As we first reported in November, the first Star Trek: Discovery soundtrack album from composer Jeff Russo has been in the works for some time — and today, CBS has officially announced the release of Star Trek: Discovery — Season 1, Chapter 1 for this month.

For those of you who prefer digital downloads, presales will begin this Friday for an availability day of December 15; sales for physical media — both on CD and vinyl — will coming early in the new year.

Here’s the full listing from this first release:

1. Main Title (Aired Version)
2. We Come In Peace
3. First Officer’s Log
4. I’ll Go
5. The Day Is Saved
6. Torchbearer
7. PTSD
8. Persistence
9. Stranded
10. What Did You Mean By That?
11. I Can’t Dance

12. Captain Mudd
13. Stella
14. Facing Off
15. Undetermined
16. Watch The Stars Fall
17. Weakened Shields
18. What’s Happening?
19. Personal Log
20. The Charge Of Mutiny
21. Main Title (Extended)

Discovery producer Alex Kurtzman praised the composer’s score in the announcement:

Grand, glorious, hopeful, heartbreaking, intimate, bittersweet, tense, soaring, surprising. Over 51 years, in its many iterations, there’s been no shortage of adjectives to describe the music of Star Trek. On the other hand, the list of composers capable of capturing them all is short, and this is where Jeff Russo comes in.

Jeff manages to hold each note in beautiful balance, evoking the nostalgia of Alexander Courage’s original theme while scoring Discovery with his own unique ear and heart. We’re lucky to have him, and we hope you’ll love his music as much as we do.

The album will be coming from Lakeshore Records, the same label who has released some of Russo’s previous work.

We’ll bring you more on this release as it arrives, and our review when available!

Novel #4:
"The Way to the Stars"


Novel #5:
"The Enterprise War"


Novel #6:
"Dead Endless"


STAR TREK 4 Update: Quentin Tarantino Developing Story

It’s been nearly a year since we last heard any news about Paramount’s sequel to Star Trek Beyond, first announced by the studio in July 2016, which at that time was said to feature the return of Thor actor Chris Hemsworth as George Kirk, reprising his role from the first Kelvin Timeline film in 2009.

Back in 2015, famed director Quentin Tarantino talked a bit during a Nerdist interview about his thoughts on Star Trek, calling out some favorite episodes like “The City on the Edge of Forever” and “Yesterday’s Enterprise,” and also expressing an issue with the current film series that forces the storytelling to include all the established characters rather than allowing a focus on the main leads (Kirk, Spock, and McCoy.)

They might have trapped themselves a little bit by the simple fact they have to use all the crew now.

In all the films they’ve established it so much, that you need Uhura, you need a Scotty, you need Bones, you need all that stuff going on all the time — everybody has to be represented in some big story where they all have to deal.

Tarantino talks Trek in that interview, also touching on the casting of Cumberbatch as Khan in Into Darkness, the greatness of “Yesterday’s Enterprise,” and more:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rzNnfKT6IrM

Now, after months of silence from the Paramount side of the franchise during the lead up and opening season of Star Trek: Discovery — remember, CBS owns the television half of Star TrekDeadline is reporting (and The Hollywood Reporter has confirmed) that Tarantino has actually pitched a story to Trek film producer J.J. Abrams, and the studio is putting together a team of writers to explore the idea.

From Deadline’s Mike Fleming, Jr.:

Sources said that Tarantino has come up with a great idea for a Star Trek movie at Paramount. After sharing his idea with JJ Abrams (who himself is busy prepping Star Wars Episode IX), I’ve heard the plan is to assemble a writers room of scribes who’ll hear Tarantino’s take and begin to put together a movie. If it all works out, Tarantino might direct it, with Abrams producing.

While Tarantino has always come up with his own original films, many have wondered what he might do if he took the reins of an existing franchise. He has only done that on television, twice directing episodes of CSI and once an episode of ER. He has spoken about the appeal of taking on one of the James Bond movies, but the hard part of something like that is getting the rights holders to give him a wide creative swath that comes along with a final cut auteur like Tarantino.

This would give a remarkable boost to the venerable franchise for Paramount, which is looking to build them under studio chief Jim Gianopulos.

Safe to say this is way too early to call Tarantino’s involvement with the Star Trek film series anything close to a done deal, and there’s no way of knowing if Tarantino’s idea even includes the current roster of Kelvin Timeline actors.

Back in 2015, Marc Evans, Paramount’s Motion Picture Group president, expressed his interest in possibly expanding the Star Trek film universe to a wider range of stories in possible future films, referencing such heaver-themed tales like Zero Dark Thirty.

Until we know more, we’re certainly filing this under “wait and see” status — but it’s nice to hear that there are still some signs of life in the Star Trek movie business.

Order
Star Trek Beyond
on Blu-ray!

Order
Star Trek Beyond
on 3D Blu-ray!

Order
Star Trek Beyond
on 4K Blu-ray!